Tuesday, November 17, 2026·Focal News

The Louisville Focal

Louisville's independent voice

Politics

Kim Davis violated asset disclosure rule in same-sex marriage case, judge finds

A federal magistrate judge ruled that former Rowan County clerk Kim Davis violated discovery rules by failing to disclose property transfers while owing more than $565,000 to the gay couple she refused to serve. Davis claims the omissions were an honest mistake, but the couple's attorneys are pushing for sanctions.

Kim Davis violated asset disclosure rule in same-sex marriage case, judge finds

A federal magistrate judge has found that Kim Davis, the former Rowan County clerk who drew international attention a decade ago for refusing to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples, violated court rules by failing to disclose her assets and property transfers while owing a six-figure judgment to one of the couples she turned away.

U.S. Magistrate Judge Edward B. Atkins ruled in early November that Davis violated discovery rules in the long-running collection case, according to court records. The ruling came in response to a motion from attorneys for David Ermold and David Moore, the couple seeking to collect a judgment now totaling more than $565,000 with fees, costs and interest. Atkins declined to hold Davis in contempt but ordered her to file updated answers about the property transfers and to explain why she should not face sanctions.

Davis filed a declaration on Nov. 16 insisting she should face no punishment. She said she believed she was answering truthfully when she stated in a court document that she owned no real property and had not transferred property worth more than $2,000.

"I had no intent then, and have no intent now, to conceal anything or to otherwise answer in any way other than the truth," Davis said in the filing.

But Michael J. Gartland, an attorney for Ermold and Moore, rejected that explanation. "This is all made up to try to get out of trouble now," he said of Davis's latest responses.

At issue are property transfers that Joseph D. Buckles, another attorney for the couple, discovered in Morehead records. According to court filings, Davis transferred houses and a 50-acre farm to family members or a trust in April and May 2025, shortly after a federal appeals court affirmed the financial judgment against her. Davis received no money for the transactions.

The property had come to Davis after her mother died without a will in January 2025, leaving Davis a 50 percent interest in the estate and bank accounts worth hundreds of thousands of dollars, Buckles and Gartland argued in court documents.

In a state court motion, the attorneys accused Davis of concealing the transfers. "No fact-finder could hear this record and find that a debtor who lost her appeal, deeded her entire inheritance to her family for nothing within weeks . . . and then denied it all under oath, acted with any purpose other than to hinder, delay, or defraud the creditors she has been promising to outlast for a decade," they wrote.

Ermold and Moore have filed a separate lawsuit in Rowan County seeking to void the property transfers. Davis has not filed a formal answer in that case.

In her federal filing, Davis said the transfers were carried out to honor her late mother's wishes and that she received nothing from the estate. "I made no personal transfers of property that I owned because I was merely the conduit and administrator transferring property in the manner that my late mother explicitly stated was her desire," she said. "My mother specifically requested that the property be distributed in the manner in which it was distributed so that the caretaking of long familial property would continue to the subsequent generations of the family."

Davis said she believed then and now that her earlier answers were true based on her understanding, and that if she was wrong, "then it was completely and honestly the result of misunderstanding or mistake, but not intent." Her attorneys, from the conservative Christian legal organization Liberty Counsel, argued that Atkins should deny sanctions because Davis did not knowingly provide false answers and had no intent to deceive.

The underlying case dates to June 2015, when the U.S. Supreme Court recognized a constitutional right to same-sex marriage. Davis, an evangelical Christian who said marriage should only be between a man and a woman, refused requests from gay couples for licenses bearing her name. Her office turned away several couples, prompting demonstrations and widespread coverage. U.S. District Judge David L. Bunning jailed Davis for several days for contempt of court.

A clerk in her office eventually issued licenses to same-sex couples, but those who had been turned away sued, arguing they had been publicly embarrassed and emotionally harmed. Davis, who lost reelection in 2018, testified at one point that "for me it was a heaven or hell issue."

Federal judges rejected her argument that personal conviction justified withholding the licenses. A federal appeals panel ruled that the First Amendment protected Davis as a private citizen but did not allow her, as a public official, to violate the rights of others. "When an official's discharge of her duties according to her conscience violates the constitutional rights of citizens, the Constitution must win out," the judges wrote.

The state of Kentucky paid $225,000 to attorneys for eight people who sued Davis, and a jury awarded $50,000 each to Ermold and Moore. With fees and interest, the judgment against Davis stood at $565,285 as of last July.

Gartland said he will continue pressing for sanctions, which could include an order that Davis pay the couple's attorney fees. The dispute now returns to Atkins, who will decide whether Davis faces a financial penalty for the incomplete disclosures.

More from The Louisville Focal