Politics
Kentucky AG Appeals Ruling That Preserves 1952 Scholarship for Black Medical Students at UofL
Attorney General Russell Coleman is appealing a judge's decision to let a decades-old, privately funded scholarship for Black medical students at the University of Louisville continue, arguing it violates the state's DEI law. The case now heads to an appeals court, with the scholarship's future in limbo.
Kentucky Attorney General Russell Coleman has appealed a judge's ruling that allows a University of Louisville scholarship for Black medical students to remain in place, escalating a legal fight over how the state's diversity, equity and inclusion law applies to privately funded bequests.
The scholarship was established through the will of Lucille Newmark, who died in 1952 and left money to help Black students attend UofL's medical school, according to court documents. For decades, the fund has supported aspiring physicians who might otherwise have been shut out of medical education.
But the scholarship's future is now entangled in a broader legal battle over Kentucky's DEI restrictions at public universities. The UofL Foundation and the attorney general's office jointly asked a judge to strip the scholarship's race-based requirement, with the foundation saying it could not locate any living relatives of Newmark to discuss the proposed change.
The judge refused, pointing to an exception in Kentucky's DEI law that permits certain privately funded scholarships created before the law took effect to continue until the fund's principal is exhausted.
Coleman's office argues that the exception only allows existing scholarships to run until their money is spent. Because Newmark's fund is designed to last indefinitely, the office contends it does not qualify for that carve-out.
In a statement, Coleman said his office is working with the UofL Foundation to ensure compliance with state law and promote fair access for Kentucky students. "It's surprising this is even a controversy in 2026," he said.
The university said in a statement that Kentucky's DEI law alone would allow most existing race- and gender-based scholarships to continue, but that its approach to administering scholarships is based on federal law and guidance. UofL also said federal officials are reviewing some of its scholarships and other benefits that consider race or gender, and emphasized that the UofL Foundation is a separate entity whose legal filings the university does not control.
James Orlick, a UofL doctoral candidate researching Kentucky's DEI law, believes the attorney general's office is targeting scholarships that lawmakers specifically allowed to continue.
"Someone died almost 70 years ago," Orlick said. "Her estate was having this impact to provide that particular opportunity. And then now it's frozen."
He said Newmark's wishes should be respected, especially since she is no longer alive to defend them.
"There's just a moral obligation," Orlick said. "There's no one coming to the court except for the judge for her and her legacy and what she wanted with her intention and her life."
The case is now headed to an appeals court as the future of Newmark's scholarship remains uncertain. The outcome could set a precedent for how Kentucky treats other privately funded, race-conscious scholarships at its public universitiesâand whether the intentions of donors long dead can survive the state's current political climate.