Politics
Kentucky Death Penalty Foes Race New Clemency Deadline After Amendment 1
Kentucky's new constitutional amendment barring late-term clemency has forced death penalty opponents to accelerate their campaign urging Gov. Andy Beshear to commute all 23 death row sentences before early September 2027. The push comes as Republicans eye the governor's office and work to restart executions after a nearly two-decade hiatus.
FRANKFORT â Kentucky death penalty opponents are launching an urgent campaign to persuade Gov. Andy Beshear to commute the sentences of all 23 people on the state's death row, after voters approved a constitutional amendment that sharply limits when governors can grant clemency.
The amendment, which passed with 71 percent support on Nov. 3, bars governors from issuing pardons, reprieves or commutations starting 60 days before an election through the end of their term. For Beshear, a term-limited Democrat, that means his clemency window closes in early September 2027 â more than a year before he leaves office in December 2027.
The Kentucky Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty plans to launch its "Do the Right Thing Andy" campaign in January, according to executive director Russell Allen. He said the amendment has added urgency to the group's work.
"It definitely gives us a sense of urgency, and we want Governor Beshear to have that same sense of urgency when he starts to look at these cases," Allen said.
The amendment was drafted by state Sen. Chris McDaniel, a Republican, in response to the controversy that erupted in late 2019 when then-Gov. Matt Bevin issued more than 400 pardons and commutations on his way out of office. Bevin faced heavy criticism over corruption allegations tied to his pardon of Patrick Baker, whose family hosted a fundraiser for Bevin that raised $21,500. Some people granted clemency by Bevin later returned to prison.
McDaniel argued the measure would prevent governors from waiting until their political accountability has faded to grant clemency. "Do not wait until electoral accountability has effectively disappeared," he wrote in an opinion piece last month.
Beshear opposed the amendment, saying his predecessor used the pardon power in "terrible ways" but that voters shouldn't let that constrain future governors. "The answer to this isn't changing the pardon power of every other governor that hasn't abused it this way, but not electing a guy like Matt Bevin ever again," he told reporters in October.
So far, Beshear's use of clemency has been limited to posthumous pardons of 43 people who helped enslaved people escape to freedom.
Kentucky's death penalty has been dormant since 2010, when Franklin Circuit Judge Phillip Shepherd blocked executions over concerns about the state's lethal injection protocols. There has not been an execution in Kentucky since 2008, and no one has been sentenced to death since 2014.
But Republicans are working to change that. Attorney General Russell Coleman has repeatedly petitioned the Kentucky Supreme Court this year to force Shepherd to lift his injunction, and the court has rebuffed those efforts. The GOP-led legislature also overrode a Beshear veto to pass legislation that allows the Department of Corrections to skip the public rulemaking process when drafting execution procedures, making it easier to resume executions.
Coleman is running for reelection next year, and Republicans hope to win back the governor's office. U.S. Rep. James Comer, one of the Republican frontrunners in the governor's race, has styled himself a champion of the death penalty.
Allen said the prospect of a Republican administration resuming executions makes Beshear's clemency decisions even more important. He pointed to President Joe Biden's decision to commute federal death row sentences before Donald Trump returned to office in 2024, and to former Oregon Gov. Kate Brown's move to empty her state's death row in 2022.
"It becomes even more important now because of the fact that he is leaving the state in an unsure place," Allen said.
Allen said he plans to make the case to Beshear that some people on death row could be innocent or should not be there because of issues such as intellectual disability.
Tim Arnold, an attorney who has worked on clemency petitions at the Kentucky Department of Public Advocacy, criticized the amendment. He said it could bar death row prisoners from seeking commutation or reprieve if their execution is scheduled during the restricted period, creating a due process concern.
"The courts might feel that there's a kind of a due process issue if what's happening is everybody else can get it, but this group of people in this time frame cannot," Arnold said.
Mark Osler, a law professor at the University of St. Thomas and an expert on clemency, said Kentucky is now the only state with time restrictions on commutations and pardons. He said the change could force governors to be more deliberate.
"There's a rush of them at the end, and it's hard to believe that they're carefully thought out," Osler said. "It's something that I think is intended to be considered regularly."
Allen said he hopes Beshear, who is seen as a possible presidential candidate in 2028, will be moved by Democratic momentum from last week's midterms.
"We think that commuting Kentucky's death row is a large signal that he believes in a new world and he's actually putting boots to ground to try to make it happen," Allen said.