Tuesday, November 17, 2026·Focal News

The Louisville Focal

Louisville's independent voice

Politics

Clark County Judge Halts Seating of Senate Pro Tem Chris Garten Over Voting Machine Discrepancy

A Clark County judge issued a temporary restraining order Monday blocking Republican Chris Garten from being seated in the Indiana Senate, after a malfunctioning voting machine recorded 28 more votes than voters in his 297-vote win over Democrat Nick Marshall.

Clark County Judge Halts Seating of Senate Pro Tem Chris Garten Over Voting Machine Discrepancy

A Clark County judge has issued a temporary restraining order preventing Republican Chris Garten from being sworn in or seated in the Indiana Senate, throwing the chamber's leadership into uncertainty just as the new session approaches.

The order, issued Monday afternoon, blocks anyone from taking the District 45 seat representing southern Indiana until questions about the election are resolved. Garten, the incumbent, leads Democratic challenger Nick Marshall by 297 votes, but the result has been clouded by a malfunctioning voting machine that was replaced on Election Day.

According to election officials, the replacement machine recorded 28 more votes than the number of voters checked in at that location — a discrepancy between the poll book and the machine's tally. The Clark County election board nonetheless certified the election.

"They wanted to confirm the election without confirming the results," said Migual Hampton, chair of the Clark County Democratic Party. "We had multiple discrepancies at multiple locations and the clerk had the chance to do their due diligence within the timeframe before certifying the vote."

Hampton argued that Garten should not be seated while the vote count remains in dispute. "Chris, Senator Garten, is not our state senator right now because the votes have not been confirmed correctly," Hampton said.

Garten, who has held the seat since 2018 and won reelection in 2022 with more than 60% of the vote, was elected by his Senate colleagues to serve as Senate Pro Tem — the chamber's top leadership post. His office did not respond to a request for comment.

The dispute carries broader significance. Garten was a leading champion of Indiana's failed effort to redraw congressional boundaries during the last general assembly, a redistricting push that drew national attention. Hampton said the closeness of this year's race reflects a changed political environment.

"That changes the trajectory and I think every voter wants their vote counted," Hampton said. "I think that's more important than forcing whatever the state senate has the capacity to do, you know, within the Constitution. I think Nick Marshall said something — 'I want to see democracy play out.' And that's what's important to this process."

The restraining order leaves the District 45 seat vacant for now and raises questions about the timing of the Senate's organization. It also puts a spotlight on election administration in Clark County, where officials certified a result despite the machine discrepancy. Supporters of Marshall have argued that the certification moved forward without adequately resolving the irregularities.

The case now heads back to court as both parties prepare for further proceedings. For voters in southern Indiana, the outcome will determine who represents them in the Senate — and whether the chamber's presiding officer takes his seat at all.

More from The Louisville Focal