Politics
Indiana Supreme Court Allows Republican Chris Garten to Take Oath in Contested District 45 Senate Race
The Indiana Supreme Court ruled that Republican Chris Garten can be sworn in for the District 45 state Senate seat despite a Democratic lawsuit seeking a recount over voting machine problems and voter record discrepancies. The court left unresolved the parts of a lower court order blocking certification and election paperwork, which will be considered later.
The Indiana Supreme Court ruled Tuesday that Republican Chris Garten can take the oath of office for the District 45 state Senate seat, even as a legal challenge to the election results remains unresolved.
Garten, of Charlestown, defeated Democrat Nick Marshall by fewer than 300 votes in the Nov. 3 election. Democrats filed a lawsuit questioning the results and seeking a recount, citing voting machine problems and discrepancies in voter records at Jeffersonville High School. The Clark County election board declined to immediately recount ballots.
A Scott County judge subsequently issued a temporary restraining order preventing the Clark County election board from certifying the results and blocking Garten from being sworn in. Garten asked the Indiana Supreme Court to intervene quickly.
In its Tuesday order, the court partly agreed with Garten, citing Article 4, Section 10 of the Indiana Constitution, which states that the ârespective houses of the legislature are the sole judges of the results of the elections of their members.â The provision means the Senate itself has final authority over its membersâ election results.
Garten was sworn in pro tempore shortly after the ruling, around 2:30 p.m. Tuesday.
The court did not vacate the entire restraining order. The portions dealing with certification and election paperwork were left unresolved and will be considered later.
Democrats also raised concerns about the Clark County auditorâs race, which was likewise decided by fewer than 300 votes.
The dispute underscores the narrow margins in several southern Indiana races and the ongoing legal questions over how contested results are certified and reviewed. While Garten can now take his seat, the fight over the election paperwork and certification continues in the courts.