Wednesday, November 18, 2026·Focal News

The San Francisco Focal

San Francisco's independent voice

Politics

SF Supervisors Unanimously Back Sweeping Reforms to Sexual Assault Investigations

All 11 San Francisco supervisors have signed onto a resolution urging the police department to overhaul its handling of rape cases, following revelations that just 14% of rapes were cleared last year and most victims' cases were quietly shelved.

SF Supervisors Unanimously Back Sweeping Reforms to Sexual Assault Investigations

SAN FRANCISCO — Every member of the Board of Supervisors has signed onto a resolution calling for major reforms to the San Francisco Police Department's handling of sexual assault cases, following reporting that exposed dismal clearance rates and hundreds of cases left uninvestigated.

Supervisor Myrna Melgar introduced the resolution Tuesday, and it carries the signatures of all 11 supervisors. A vote is scheduled for Dec. 1.

"We were all troubled to read the stories of survivors ... on how even in the most perfect examples of following everything you're supposed to do after a sexual assault, the cases would end up being deemed inactive," Melgar said at Tuesday's hearing.

The resolution follows an Oct. 8 joint special hearing called in response to a July investigative report that detailed the department's poor record on rape and sexual assault cases. That report found the SFPD cleared just 14% of rape cases last year — half the national rate and the lowest of any large California county in the past five years. In 2025, more than 300 victims underwent hours-long, invasive rape exams at San Francisco General Hospital, only for 78% of their cases to be labeled "inactive" — a department term for cases that are technically open but not being investigated.

The resolution, though not legally binding, is a formal policy statement by the board. It asks the SFPD to require new training for Special Victims Unit investigators and patrol officers, including trauma-informed interviewing and accurate labeling of sex-crime reports so cases are properly investigated. It also calls for connecting victims with community advocates or sexual assault counselors.

The recommendations are based on "extensive research into the best practices currently utilized by law enforcement agencies nationally and internationally" conducted by the Mayor's Office for Victims' Rights, according to the resolution.

Among its specific requests: that police apply the probable-cause standard when making arrests rather than seeking permission from the district attorney, which relies on the higher beyond-a-reasonable-doubt burden; that investigations focus on "corroborating or contradicting the suspect's account and behavior" rather than the victim's; and that investigators regularly update victims on the status of their cases.

The resolution also asks the department to establish a protocol for assigning sexual assault cases to investigators and to ideally contact victims within 48 hours of a report. It calls for a new protocol of "baseline investigative steps that need to be taken" before a case is closed or deemed inactive, and for explaining to victims the reason behind their case status. It further requests that the SFPD publish department guidelines for sexual assault investigations and create a public dashboard of outcomes.

Additionally, the resolution directs the SFPD to create an internal "accountability matrix" to track progress on implementing changes, and to assess staffing in the Special Victims Unit, assign "reasonable" caseloads, and work on recruitment and retention. The department has often cited low staffing as a reason for its poor record.

Finally, the board urges the SFPD to implement the "Philadelphia Model" — a yearly independent audit of sexual assault cases "to identify patterns, trends, systemic issues, and procedural gaps." The Women's Law Project, which has run the Philadelphia Police Department's advocate review for 26 years, submitted testimony before the Oct. 8 hearing urging San Francisco to adopt the model and offering to help build it.

Mayor Daniel Lurie expressed support for reforms to sexual assault cases in a speech to the Board of Supervisors on Oct. 20. After the Dec. 1 vote, the resolution will be sent to the Police Commission, which will hold its own hearing on sexual assault the following day, according to Secretary Stacy Youngblood. Unlike the Board of Supervisors, the Police Commission has the authority to dictate SFPD policy.

Alongside the reforms, the SFPD will present its latest report on the status of rape-kit cases from the first half of 2026. In October, reporting revealed that the numbers had yet to improve: between January and June of this year, 170 sexual assault victims underwent rape-kit exams in San Francisco, yet as of October police had made only 11 arrests based on those alleged assaults, and only one case is being prosecuted as a sex crime.

The push for reform comes as survivors and advocates have grown increasingly vocal about what they describe as a systemic failure to investigate sexual violence. The unanimous board support signals rare political consensus on an issue that has drawn national scrutiny to San Francisco's law enforcement practices.

More from The San Francisco Focal