Politics
San Francisco Historic Landmark Bill Shelved After YIMBY Pushback, Exposing Mandelman-Mahmood Rift
A proposal to speed up historic landmarking in San Francisco was indefinitely postponed Monday after YIMBY-aligned Supervisor Bilal Mahmood pushed an amendment requiring the city to offset any housing lost to preservation. The fight is a proxy for the 2028 Assembly race between Mahmood and Supervisor Rafael Mandelman.
A San Francisco Board of Supervisors committee voted Monday to indefinitely postpone legislation that would have streamlined the creation of historic landmarks, handing a victory to pro-housing advocates who argued the bill could choke off new construction.
The Land Use Committee's decision followed pushback from YIMBY groups and a rival amendment from Supervisor Bilal Mahmood that Supervisor Rafael Mandelman, the bill's author, said would have gutted the measure. The legislation would have reduced the number of hearings required to designate a historic landmark, shortening a process that can stretch for years.
The dispute also laid bare a broader political rivalry. Mandelman and Mahmood are widely expected to compete for a California State Assembly seat in 2028. Mandelman has already opened a campaign committee for the contest, while Mahmood has denied he is running, though many political observers expect him to enter. The seat is currently held by Matt Haney, who is running next year for the State Senate seat held by Scott Wiener, who is departing for Congress.
Mandelman and Mayor Daniel Lurie unveiled the landmarking bill in May as part of a larger push to expand the city's historic register. They proposed a citywide survey to identify buildings worthy of protection and aim to add roughly 2,500 new landmarks, more than doubling San Francisco's current count. That survey effort will continue despite the legislation being shelved.
Mandelman, who voted for last year's upzoning measure, said preservation and housing production should go hand in hand. "If we do not get ahead of the game with historic preservation, we could see the ministerial demolition of important historic resources without any real process to try to save them," he said.
Mahmood planned to introduce an amendment at Monday's hearing that would have required the city to evaluate how much housing could have been built on a site slated for landmarking, then force an upzoning elsewhere to offset the lost capacity. "We're in an affordability crisis right now," Mahmood said. "San Franciscans want us to be doing everything in our power to make it easier to build housing." He also argued that without such an amendment, the city could face lawsuits under state requirements to balance development constraints with new building opportunities.
Mandelman called the amendment a dealbreaker and pulled the legislation. He had already removed Mahmood from the Land Use Committee in August, citing the planned amendments. "His approach to my historic preservation legislation has been quite aggressive," Mandelman said at the time. With Mahmood off the committee, Supervisor Myrna Melgar agreed to carry the amendment for him, prompting Mandelman to withdraw the bill.
YIMBY Action organizing director Brandon Powell praised Mahmood's role. "We are extremely grateful to Supervisor Mahmood for his work to ensure that historic preservation doesn't prevent the building of much needed housing in San Francisco," Powell said. "We wish that Supervisor Mandelman had considered the production of housing to be as important as the protection of some random number of buildings in the city, but apparently he did not."
Mandelman rejected that framing. "I understand that there are concerns about any directionality towards more preservation in the city," he said. "I think it's wrong and I think it's a mistake."
The committee's decision leaves the landmarking expansion without its legislative vehicle for now, even as the citywide survey moves forward. For residents in neighborhoods like the Sunset, where rows of pastel houses have drawn preservation interest, the outcome signals that any future landmark designations will continue to face the same lengthy approval process â and the same political crosswinds.