Tuesday, November 17, 2026·Focal News

The San Francisco Focal

San Francisco's independent voice

Politics

Newsom Faces Supreme Court Challenge Over Plan to Commute 548 Death Sentences

A victim rights group representing 30 district attorneys and two dozen victims' families has asked the California Supreme Court to block Gov. Gavin Newsom's plan to commute the sentences of all 548 people on death row, arguing he bypassed required victim notification and individualized review.

Newsom Faces Supreme Court Challenge Over Plan to Commute 548 Death Sentences

A coalition of prosecutors and victims' family members has asked the California Supreme Court to halt Gov. Gavin Newsom's plan to commute the sentences of everyone on the state's death row, setting up a high-stakes legal fight over the limits of gubernatorial clemency.

The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation filed the action Monday on behalf of 30 county district attorneys and more than two dozen relatives of murder victims. The suit argues that Newsom exceeded his authority by moving to re-sentence 548 condemned prisoners — 529 men and 19 women — without giving victims proper notice or the chance to be heard, and without the individualized review the law requires.

"Governor Newsom decided his personal views should override all those who actually participated in the process, followed and applied the law," wrote Anne Marie Schubert, the foundation's president and CEO and a former Sacramento County district attorney. The filing contends that "thousands of jurors and hundreds of judges set aside their personal views on the merits of the death penalty to render judgments based on the evidence and the law."

Newsom announced earlier this month that he intends to commute every death sentence in California, writing in an open letter to constituents that "state-sanctioned killing is incompatible" with the state's values and calling the decision "among the most difficult of my career." The governor's office did not immediately respond to a request for comment Tuesday.

Because the state constitution requires the California Supreme Court to approve clemency for anyone convicted of more than one felony, the court would have to sign off on 382 of the proposed commutations, according to Newsom.

Whether a governor can issue a blanket commutation is largely uncharted territory. "This is all new and we don't really have answers," said Michael Vitiello, a professor at the University of the Pacific's McGeorge School of Law. "There's no record of a previous mass commutation. This is not something that we have a great deal of precedent" on.

Hadar Aviram, a professor at UC Law San Francisco, said the governor's action is not subject to extensive judicial scrutiny absent a detailed mandate for review. "This is an executive decision, it's not a judicial decision," she said. "It doesn't require any sort of legal proceedings with respect to each person individually. There is nothing to stop the governor from using this authority."

While the plaintiffs appear to have broad backing from law enforcement, some prosecutors support the governor's move. "As a prosecutor, I believe that we will remain safer from crime and injustice as long as we believe that we can and should change outdated and ineffective practices like the death penalty," said five-term Santa Clara County District Attorney Jeff Rosen, in a statement released by the criminal justice reform group Smart Justice California. "We will be a safer community if we never lose faith in human dignity, including our own."

California has not executed a prisoner since Jan. 17, 2006, when Clarence Ray Allen was put to death by lethal injection. The lawsuit now puts the future of the nation's largest death row before the state's highest court, with profound implications for victims' families, condemned inmates and a capital punishment system that has long been dormant in practice.

More from The San Francisco Focal