Local
SFMTA Staff Fired After Emails Reveal They Knowingly Leased City Garage to ICE
Internal emails show two SFMTA staffers approved additional parking spaces for ICE at a city-owned garage, prioritizing revenue over San Francisco's sanctuary law. Both employees were fired, but ICE vehicles remain at the Golden Gateway Garage despite city demands for their removal.
Two San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency staff members were fired after internal emails revealed they knowingly approved a lease expansion for U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement at a city-owned parking garage, in direct violation of San Francisco's sanctuary ordinance, according to records obtained through a public records request.
The emails, dated between April 16 and September 25, show SFMTA staff facilitating ICE's request for 63 additional parking spaces at the Golden Gateway Garage at 250 Clay St., just three blocks from the city's ICE field office. The garage has housed federal agency vehicles since 2010, but the exchange reveals staff prioritized revenue over the city's longstanding prohibition on assisting immigration enforcement.
"Where is [this] for again? If we have the space, I don't mind taking the money," one SFMTA staffer wrote on April 22, after a colleague forwarded a request from the garage's private operator, IMCO Parking, seeking more spaces for ICE at $430 to $500 per month per spot.
The colleague had written minutes earlier: "Thoughts? It is revenue, afterallâ¦."
The emails were heavily redacted, with employee names and addresses obscured. But they document a clear sequence: On April 16, an IMCO employee emailed SFMTA staff saying ICE wanted to add more spaces. An SFMTA worker requested details on the "current deal with ICE" and on April 20 wrote, "Approved to proceed." By August, staff were arranging DocuSign signatures for the lease, and the contract was ratified in September.
"We are all set to move in," an ICE staffer wrote on Sept. 24. The following day, a parking operator employee thanked a redacted recipient "for the support in this negotiation with Uncle Sam."
Angela Chan, an assistant chief at the public defender's office who helped author both city and state sanctuary laws, said the exchanges represent flagrant violations of the Sanctuary Ordinance and the ICE Free Zones Ordinance, which prohibit the use of city resources for immigration enforcement.
"They effectively turned part of a city garage into a staging ground for immigration raids throughout the Bay Area," Chan said.
The prohibition against working with ICE should not have surprised SFMTA employees. An all-staff memo in January 2025 reminded them that "City agencies and employees are generally prohibited from using city resources to assist ICE in enforcing federal immigration laws."
SFMTA leadership said it was unaware of the staffers' actions until the issue was raised last month, following reporting that ICE vehicles were parked at the garage. Both staffers were subsequently fired, according to a department source and Supervisor Bilal Mahmood.
SFMTA Director of Transportation Julie Kirschbaum said in a statement that the agency is "deeply concerned about what we have learned in recent weeks" and is working with the City Attorney's office "to find a legal pathway to remove ICE from our garage."
The agency has said it is "not a party" to the agreements between IMCO and the federal government, which "creates complications for the legal path forward." But the city retains "sole discretion" to terminate the parking garage contract, and critics argue the agency could act if it chose to.
"If they allow this to continue, it is because they are choosing to do so," said David Campos, a former deputy city attorney and former supervisor who authored a key amendment to the sanctuary ordinance.
ICE had been paying over $300,000 annually for 84 spaces in the garage since 2024, according to the emails. The additional 63 spaces would have more than doubled the contract's value. ICE vehicles have been in the garage for at least 16 years, documents show, and activists monitoring the site say they have been used to transport agents and detained immigrants to and from enforcement operations.
Since the contract was publicized on Oct. 30, SFMTA has consulted with the City Attorney's office and on Nov. 2 wrote a letter to the federal government asking it to "immediately remove" the ICE vehicles. In a Nov. 18 letter to Mahmood, the agency said parking garages would moving forward be managed directly by SFMTA rather than private subcontractors.
Mayor Daniel Lurie's spokesperson, Shelby Weiss, did not answer questions about whether the city would cancel the contract, reiterating only that "city resources cannot be used for civil immigration enforcement" and that the city is exploring "all options to remove the vehicles."
IMCO, the garage operator, is a major city contractor managing 15 of 48 SFMTA parking facilities. Its parent company, Reimagined Parking, did not respond to a request for comment.
The revelations come as hundreds of immigrants have been detained at the nearby ICE field office or taken there after arrests across the Bay Area. Community activists have spent months monitoring the garage, documenting ICE vehicles used in enforcement operations.
The episode raises questions about oversight at SFMTA and whether the city will take decisive action to end its entanglement with federal immigration enforcement. For now, ICE vehicles remain parked in a city-owned garage, and the agency that leased them the space says it is still searching for a way to make them leave.