Local
California Board to Vote on Pepper Spray Use in Juvenile Halls
The Board of State and Community Corrections votes Thursday on whether to ban chemical agents like pepper spray in county juvenile detention facilities or keep them with expanded reporting. Youth advocates and formerly incarcerated youth are pressing for a ban as the state shifts juvenile justice responsibilities to counties.
A California regulatory board is set to decide Thursday whether corrections officers may continue using chemical agents such as pepper spray and tear gas on young people held in county juvenile detention facilities.
The 15-member Board of State and Community Corrections (BSCC) â appointed by the governor and Legislature and made up of probation officials, sheriffs and criminal justice advocates â oversees rules for the state's adult and youth justice systems, conducts inspections, sets training standards and administers public safety grants. Its vote comes as counties assume greater responsibility following the closure of the state Department of Juvenile Justice and the transfer of its duties to local governments.
The decision is the product of a four-year periodic review of juvenile hall conditions. A BSCC steering committee convened working groups on education, environmental health, nutrition and medical and mental health. Young people with experience in California's juvenile halls successfully pushed the committee to propose new language guaranteeing more food, including two hot meals a day; expanding visits beyond relatives; and reducing how often youth are pulled from school as punishment, among other changes.
"There was a bit of a surprise when every time [BSCC] was holding a meeting of their committee, they have 20, 30 youth in the audience in this out-of-the-way boardroom in northern Sacramento," said Colin Ford, director of policy at Fresh Lifelines for Youth, or FLY, which supports Bay Area youth affected by the criminal justice system.
The most contentious issue is chemical agents as a use-of-force tactic. At its July meeting, the steering committee advanced two options: ban them outright, or keep them while requiring routine reporting on all uses of force.
"I asked for [the reporting element], and it was supported by everyone," said Meredith Desautels, a steering committee member and attorney with the Youth Law Center in San Francisco. "I do think it's something that they should be pressured to prioritize because it's an entirely county-based system with youth spending long periods of time there, and there are going to be a lot of policy decisions to be made about the youth justice system in the coming years, as we continue to improve and refine these reforms."
Advocates were dismayed when the BSCC narrowed the reporting requirement to cover only chemical agents. BSCC spokesperson Jana Sanford-Miller said in a statement that the board "determines much of our operational direction" and "also has the ability to make modifications to the draft regulations during the publicly accessible meeting." During the hearing, she added: "Expecting our officers to physically overpower grown men without an intermediate tool is simply unsafe and unrealistic."
Diego Ballasteros, a 19-year-old college student and single father who lives in Santa Clara County, has been pushing for a ban on chemical agents and other systemic reforms. "It feels like it's an attack on youth. All these people are animalistic," he said.
Ballasteros said he was held at Santa Clara County Juvenile Hall for two weeks at age 16 for a property crime. He described the experience as overwhelmingly negative, though he recalled that some staff de-escalated situations without chemical agents or other use-of-force tactics. Santa Clara County's probation department ended pepper spray use at its youth facilities in 2015.
"Being incarcerated, I really felt like everything was over. Like I wouldn't be able to see my son. I lost my employment [and] wouldn't be able to work toward my high school diploma," Ballasteros said. "It was a really scary time in my life, and I felt really alone. I had conversations with super young children, and they shouldn't be in this environment."
The vote carries particular weight as counties take on responsibilities once held by the state. Advocates argue that with youth spending long stretches in county facilities, consistent statewide standards and transparent reporting on use of force are essential to protecting young people and ensuring accountability in a decentralized system.