Local
Troy McAlister Accepts 21-Year Plea Deal in 2020 SoMa Crash That Killed Two Pedestrians
Troy McAlister, whose case became a flashpoint in the 2022 recall of District Attorney Chesa Boudin, pleaded guilty Wednesday to two counts of gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated for the 2020 crash that killed Hanako Abe and Elizabeth Platt. He faces 21 years and four months, with roughly 12 years expected to be credited for time served.
SAN FRANCISCO â Troy McAlister, the man whose fatal 2020 crash in SoMa became a rallying cry for the campaign that recalled District Attorney Chesa Boudin, agreed Wednesday to a plea deal that will effectively close the case against him.
Judge Eric Fleming accepted the agreement at the Hall of Justice, convicting McAlister of two counts of gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated and one count related to a stolen vehicle. The sentence totals 21 years and four months, though McAlister is expected to receive about 12 years of credit for time already served. His formal sentencing is set for Dec. 11, when the credit will be calculated.
The charges stem from Dec. 31, 2020, when McAlister drove a stolen car through a red light at Second and Mission streets, struck another vehicle and careened into two pedestrians. Hanako Abe, 27, and Elizabeth Platt, 60, were killed.
McAlister, who grew up in Bayview, was on parole at the time. He had cycled in and out of prison for drug and theft offenses since age 19. In 2015 he was arrested for robbing a market with an airsoft gun and, because of prior convictions, was eligible for sentencing under California's three-strikes law, which carries a mandatory 25-years-to-life term for a third felony.
When Boudin took office in early 2020, McAlister was still jailed awaiting sentencing in that robbery case. Boudin, who ran on a progressive platform and opposed the three-strikes law, had directed prosecutors in most cases to charge only the crime at hand rather than defendants' prior records. McAlister's exposure in the 2015 case dropped from a possible life term to five years â time he had already served â and he was released on parole in April 2020.
Over the following year, McAlister was arrested four more times on drug or property allegations but was not charged, instead referred to parole authorities. State parole officials never revoked his parole. On Dec. 29, 2020, he allegedly stole a car belonging to a woman he had met on a dating app; two days later, authorities say, he was driving that car while high on methamphetamine when he ran the red light and killed Abe and Platt.
The case quickly became a political flashpoint. Brooke Jenkins, then a little-known prosecutor in Boudin's office, forwarded McAlister's confidential case files to a colleague's personal email in October 2021, despite neither being assigned to the case, according to reporting at the time. Both Jenkins and that colleague, Don du Bain, resigned within a week and soon worked on the recall campaign. Details from the files surfaced in pro-recall materials, and the McAlister case featured prominently in campaign advertising, including an ad featuring Hiroko Abe, Hanako Abe's mother.
Boudin was recalled in 2022. Jenkins was appointed to succeed him and later won election and reelection. Last year, the State Bar of California determined that Jenkins' handling of the confidential materials was unethical and ordered her into a diversion program â a finding that came years after the recall.
McAlister's case has been prosecuted by Jenkins' office since then. Assistant District Attorney Kourtney Bell helped negotiate Wednesday's agreement.
After the hearing, Jenkins said she wished the case could have incorporated more of McAlister's prior convictions, potentially yielding a life sentence. But she said Boudin's office had filed the original charges, and she feared that if her office increased them, judges worried about politicization might recuse her prosecutors. Her office opted for the plea after weighing the risk that a trial could produce a lighter sentence.
"This is probably one of the toughest decisions we have ever had to make," Jenkins said. "This isn't a day where we feel any relief. This is a tough day."
Judge Fleming called the agreement "fair" and "reasonable" given the circumstances of the case. The victims' families expressed divergent views.
Alison Platt, Elizabeth Platt's sister, thanked the attorneys for reaching a resolution and sparing her family a lengthy jury trial. "After all these years we believe it'd be helpful to reach some closure at this time," she said.
Hiroko Abe, speaking through a Japanese-language interpreter, said she had wanted a trial. She said she was not seeking a long sentence so much as a public accounting of what happened. "What I am seeking now is to make public and make clear what happened up to now, so that the citizens would understand well what the term of his sentence is going to be, so that the people of San Francisco can live in safety," she told the court.
Boudin, in earlier remarks about the case, said: "We all lie awake at night wondering what we could have done differently."