Friday, November 20, 2026·Focal News

The Phoenix Focal

Phoenix's independent voice

Politics

Maricopa County Prosecutor Declines Charges Against Eight Noncitizens Who Voted, Citing State Registration Glitch

Maricopa County Attorney Rachel Mitchell announced Wednesday that eight noncitizens who were mistakenly registered to vote and cast ballots will not be prosecuted, citing a government registration error. The eight individuals, all legal residents, voted a combined 16 times from 2012 to 2025, but Mitchell said a jury would not convict them given the systemic glitch.

Maricopa County Prosecutor Declines Charges Against Eight Noncitizens Who Voted, Citing State Registration Glitch

Maricopa County Attorney Rachel Mitchell said Wednesday that her office will not file charges against eight noncitizens who were erroneously registered to vote and cast ballots, citing a state registration system error that she said would make convictions unlikely.

"We will not be filing charges in those cases," Mitchell said at a news conference. "It's my feeling that a jury would not convict these eight individuals because of the involvement of a government-involved glitch, if you will."

The eight individuals were among 60 suspected noncitizen voters referred to the county attorney's office in March by Maricopa County Recorder Justin Heap. The referrals followed a review of more than 60,000 registered voters affected by a glitch in the Arizona Motor Vehicle Division's registration system that dates back to 2004 and was discovered in 2024. The error caused some people who obtained driver's licenses before October 1, 1996—when the MVD began requiring proof of citizenship—to be mistakenly classified as having already provided that proof.

The Recorder's Office ran the affected voters through the federal SAVE database, which flagged 207 names. Investigators confirmed that 60 of those individuals had actually voted at least once, narrowing the probe to that group. In September, Mitchell announced that 52 of the 60 were confirmed U.S. citizens, leaving eight noncitizens.

According to Mitchell, all eight were in the country legally. Two were registered Republicans, one was a Democrat, and five had no party affiliation. They cast a combined 16 ballots between 2012 and 2025, with no more than three voting in any single election—not enough to alter the outcome of any race.

Mitchell said the state registration error was responsible for seven of the eight cases. "In talking to individuals, they thought, 'Well, if I'm being sent a ballot, I guess it's OK for me to vote,'" she said.

The eighth person filled out a registration form and checked a box indicating they were not a citizen but still received a ballot.

While the eight cases are closed, Mitchell said her office is conducting a systemic review of voter registration processes and is calling for legislation to close the loophole. She emphasized that the number of improper voters was too small to sway an election.

The decision comes as Arizona election officials continue to grapple with the fallout from the MVD glitch, which has raised questions about the integrity of voter rolls and the safeguards meant to prevent noncitizens from casting ballots. The county's top prosecutor said the cases highlight the need for clearer procedures and better coordination between state agencies.

Mitchell's announcement drew a mix of reactions. Some voting-rights advocates welcomed the decision not to prosecute individuals who relied on government-issued ballots, while others said the episode underscores the importance of accurate voter registration systems.

The Maricopa County Recorder's Office did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the prosecutor's decision or the proposed legislative fix.

More from The Phoenix Focal