Politics
Maricopa County Certifies Election After Record-Setting Count, But Thousands of Rejected Ballots Raise Questions
Maricopa County posted 99% of its election results by the Friday after Election Day â the fastest count in at least 20 years â but the certification meeting was overshadowed by a tripling of mail ballots rejected for signature problems and the recorder's absence.
Maricopa County supervisors certified the Nov. 3 election results Wednesday after the county posted 99% of its results by the Friday following Election Day â the fastest count in at least two decades. But the meeting was dominated by a sharp rise in mail ballots rejected over signature problems and the absence of the county official whose office oversees those checks.
Supervisor Thomas Galvin, a Republican, said 6,089 ballots were rejected for signature issues this year, compared with roughly 1,800 in 2022, even though turnout was similar in both elections. "That's like a tripling number," Galvin said. "I think we dodged a bullet here because the elections were not close this year."
Recorder Justin Heap, whose office verifies signatures, did not attend the meeting, leaving an empty chair behind his name placard. That meant county election staff could not answer Galvin's questions about the spike. "The recorder's not here, correct?" Galvin asked. "That's correct," replied Zach Shearer, the assistant county manager for elections.
Supervisors nonetheless had no choice but to certify. Tom Liddy of the Maricopa County Attorney's Office told the board the certification is mandatory under state law and must be completed by midnight Thursday. "It's a ministerial duty. It's not a discretionary duty," Liddy said. "You shall do it."
At a separate briefing Wednesday, Heap said the higher rejection figure shows his office is now verifying signatures correctly. He said critics, including board members, have not observed the process firsthand. "Not a single member of the board has come down to actually look at the signatures," Heap said. "It's because they don't match."
Supervisor Mark Stewart, also a Republican, acknowledged the new process may be catching problems that previously went undetected. "Maybe in 2022 some signatures slip through that maybe shouldn't have slipped through," Stewart said. "We need to get to the bottom of it."
Supervisor Steve Gallardo, a Democrat, criticized Heap for skipping the meeting. "It's very disturbing that Mr. Heap is not here," Gallardo said. "Once again, just showing that he's not really taking his job serious."
The fast count marks a notable shift for a county that has repeatedly drawn national scrutiny over how long it takes to tally results. One race remains unresolved: an automatic recount begins Monday for a state House seat in Legislative District 27.
The rejected ballots are likely to remain a point of contention. With thousands of voters' mail ballots disqualified over signature mismatches â and no explanation offered at the certification meeting â the episode underscores the stakes of the county's signature-verification process, which can determine whether a ballot is counted at all. County officials have not said how many of those voters were notified or given a chance to cure their ballots.