Politics
Wisconsin Audit Faults DPI on School Report Cards and Testing Procedures
A Legislative Audit Bureau review found the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction lacked written policies for key testing procedures and omitted required information from school accountability reports. Superintendent Jill Underly dismissed the audit as factually incorrect and politically motivated.
MADISON, Wis. â A new audit from the Wisconsin Legislative Audit Bureau has found that the state Department of Public Instruction (DPI) operated without written policies for several key student testing procedures and failed to include all legally required information in its annual school accountability reports.
The audit, released this week, examined how DPI sets academic standards, administers assessments, and produces report cards for schools and districts across Wisconsin. While state law does not require DPI to establish academic standards, it does mandate that the department use assessment results and other data to generate annual report cards.
According to the audit, DPI lacked written policies governing changes to the performance categories used to classify student scores on the Wisconsin Forward Exam, PreACT Secure, and ACT. From 2016 through 2023, the department used four categories: below basic, basic, proficient, and advanced. In June 2024, DPI announced a shift to new labels: developing, approaching, meeting, and advanced.
Auditors said the department had no written policies for making those changes and instead relied on the knowledge and experience of staff and vendors. Similarly, DPI lacked written policies for updating the Forward Exam to align with revisions to academic standards made in 2020 and 2021, a process the department changed over time.
The audit also found that DPI adjusted achievement scores on 2023-24 report cards to account for changes to the Forward Exam so that scores would not fall below the previous yearâs levels. Additionally, auditors determined that accountability reports for the 2023-24 and 2024-25 school years omitted some information required by law, and that the department failed to produce school performance reports as mandated.
The findings come as DPI released its latest round of school report cards on Tuesday, which showed the Madison Metropolitan School District and eight neighboring districts met or exceeded expectations.
State Superintendent Jill Underly pushed back sharply on the audit in a statement Friday, saying the bureau had not contacted DPI since April and that the review offered nothing new.
âInstead of providing meaningful new information and recommendations, the audit makes factually incorrect assertions, goes beyond the scope of its review, and reads like a continuation of last legislative sessionâs partisan political theater rather than a review conducted in good faith,â Underly said.
The audit includes 13 recommendations for the department and identifies one issue for lawmakers to consider. The findings add to ongoing scrutiny of how Wisconsin measures school performance and communicates results to families, with implications for accountability and public trust in the stateâs education system.