Saturday, November 21, 2026·Focal News

The Madison Focal

Madison's independent voice

Politics

Brown County Judge Tosses Election Bribery Lawsuit Against Elon Musk Over 2025 Wisconsin Supreme Court Race

A Brown County judge dismissed a lawsuit accusing Elon Musk of election bribery for handing out $1 million checks at a Green Bay rally before Wisconsin's 2025 Supreme Court election, ruling that the plaintiffs lacked standing. The decision is a setback for voting-rights advocates, but a separate criminal referral remains with a special prosecutor who declined to charge Musk.

Brown County Judge Tosses Election Bribery Lawsuit Against Elon Musk Over 2025 Wisconsin Supreme Court Race

A Brown County judge has dismissed a lawsuit accusing Elon Musk of election bribery and other offenses for giving two $1 million checks to voters at a Green Bay rally ahead of Wisconsin's 2025 state Supreme Court election.

Judge Marc Hammer ruled late Wednesday that the plaintiffs—two individual voters and the Wisconsin Democracy Campaign—lacked standing to bring the case. In his written decision, Hammer said standing "restricts access to judicial remedies to those who have suffered some injury because of something that someone has either done or not done."

The voters' claim that Musk had "undermined Wisconsin's democracy" was "not a concrete enough injury to give rise to standing," the judge wrote. He similarly rejected the Democracy Campaign's argument that Musk's actions forced the group to spend more time and resources on combating corruption, noting the organization did not claim it was blocked "from carrying out its mission of election advocacy, just that it had to use more effort and resources to do so."

The lawsuit, filed in June 2025, argued that Wisconsin law prohibits offering anyone more than $1 to induce them to go to the polls, vote, or vote for a particular candidate. The case was originally filed in Dane County and later moved to Brown County, where the rally took place.

Law Forward, a Madison-based nonprofit law firm focused on democracy and voting rights, represented the plaintiffs along with the Democracy Defenders Fund in Washington, D.C., and the law firm Hecker Fink.

"Wisconsin voters understand that doling out millions of dollars to induce people to vote is wrong," said Scott Thompson, staff counsel at Law Forward. He called the dismissal "a setback, but by no means the end of the road," adding: "We will press forward and continue to stand up for free and fair elections."

Musk and his political action committee, America PAC, spent more than $20 million on the race between Dane County Judge Susan Crawford and Waukesha County Judge Brad Schimel. Crawford won what became the most expensive judicial campaign in American history.

Before the election, America PAC offered voters $100 to sign a petition "in opposition to activist judges" and another $100 for referring other voters to sign. At the Green Bay rally, Musk handed out two $1 million checks that had been advertised as awards "in appreciation for you taking the time to vote."

The civil lawsuit is separate from a criminal referral made earlier this year by the Wisconsin Elections Commission, which voted 5-1 to send two complaints to the Brown County district attorney's office alleging Musk violated the state's election bribery law. That case was referred to a special prosecutor, La Crosse County District Attorney Tim Gruenke, who concluded the accusation was based on "a poorly worded statement" Musk made on X and later corrected. Gruenke declined to file charges, saying a jury would be unlikely to convict Musk.

The dismissal leaves the civil case closed at the circuit court level, though Law Forward's statement suggests an appeal may be forthcoming. The ruling also underscores the difficulty of using civil courts to challenge big-money influence in elections, even in a state where the law explicitly limits payments tied to voting.

More from The Madison Focal