Saturday, November 21, 2026·Focal News

The Madison Focal

Madison's independent voice

Politics

Madison Mayoral Candidates React to DA's Decision Not to Charge Officer in Corey Ruiz Killing

Ten candidates for Madison mayor weighed in on Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne's decision not to charge Officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson in the July 22 killing of Corey Ruiz, with most calling for systemic change but few offering specifics.

Madison Mayoral Candidates React to DA's Decision Not to Charge Officer in Corey Ruiz Killing

MADISON — The ten announced candidates for Madison mayor responded Thursday to Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne's decision not to file charges against the Madison police officer who killed Corey Ruiz on July 22, offering condolences and calls for change while acknowledging the limited power the mayor's office holds over both the district attorney and the police department.

Ozanne announced the charging decision Thursday. Officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson, who shot Ruiz, will not face criminal prosecution. According to attorney Ben Crump, who represents the Ruiz family, Ozanne said he did not believe the officer suffered any significant injury and that the officer was not stabbed. Photos of Baitinger-Peterson included in the state Division of Criminal Investigation report show small patches of apparent injuries that are redacted.

Mayor Satya Rhodes-Conway, in a statement, wrote that "the narrow focus of whether criminal charges were warranted for this incident doesn't change the fact that Corey Ruiz should be alive." She noted that state law prohibits the mayor and Common Council from suspending, disciplining, or terminating individual police officers, and that only the Madison Police and Fire Commission — a creation of state law — holds that authority. "In my opinion, it's difficult for the Madison Police Department to have the trust of the community while officers involved in shootings remain on the force. But it's not up to me," she wrote. "I hope they will seriously examine this case and take action."

The next mayor will have limited direct control over the police department. The Police and Fire Commission handles hiring, promotion, discipline, and firing of police personnel, and the district attorney is a county-level elected office with its own prosecutorial discretion.

Former City Council President Syed Abbas called Ruiz's death a "tragedy" and said he was "heartbroken" by the decision. "The District Attorney's decision not to pursue criminal charges is not the end of this conversation. It does not erase the loss of a life, resolve the community's concerns, or relieve our public institutions of their responsibility to answer to the people they serve," he said. Abbas said the moment "reflects a broader failure in our system" and that Black residents and communities of color in Madison "continue to bear a disproportionate burden of police violence." He called for "transparency, independent oversight, and a willingness to change when our systems fall short."

Former Ald. Brian Benford wrote that the decision "came as no surprise, yet it still lands heavily on all of us." He urged the community to "pause, put his loved ones first, and allow them the space, dignity, and support they deserve." Benford, who has called for a truth and reconciliation process over Madison's disparities and racial divide, added that "while justice did not happen today, our resolve has not wavered" and called for "real, lasting systemic changes."

Kaleem Caire, president of One City Schools, stood with Ruiz's family as they addressed media Thursday. He wrote that the family "received news they did not deserve," noting that Ruiz's daughter, Kah'Liyah Aliomar, attended One City Schools for several years and her mother, Marjorie, was an active member of the parent council. Caire said Baitinger-Peterson "should have been charged with reckless homicide" and argued there should have been a trial. "When the facts are this contested, with no body camera footage and only bystander video, that is exactly when 12 members of our community should weigh the evidence and decide," he wrote. Caire, who said he has been friends with Ozanne since childhood, called the decision "wrong" and said it would "deepen distrust" in the district attorney's office and law enforcement.

Natalia Hacerola, a self-described "(w)rap artist" who performs activist art by wrapping sites where police have killed people with fabric, was part of a crowd at the Dane County Coroner's Office in McFarland as Ruiz's family met with Ozanne. She later posted a poem to Facebook writing that "#justice has been consistently elusive."

Jason Ilstrup, president of Downtown Madison Inc., wrote that "everyone in Madison deserves to be safe and to be treated with dignity, in every neighborhood and in every interaction with our city." He acknowledged the anger of protesters while attempting to clarify the district attorney's role, and challenged residents to work on solutions. "This cannot be where accountability ends," he wrote. "A charging decision does not rebuild trust — that work belongs to all of us."

Jonny Hinds, a personal trainer, has not issued a public statement on the decision but has previously called for better fitness training for Madison police officers to de-escalate situations. Hinds has described a close relationship with Gregory Velasquez, who was shot and killed by Madison police in 2004 after walking into the Red Caboose Child Care Center armed with two meat cleavers. Hinds said both Ruiz and Velasquez were unhoused and carried knives for "survival on the street." "It's the same friggin' thing," Hinds said. "The cops here run through a bogus training protocol."

Alec Hogoboom, who runs social media accounts under the name "Mr. Madison News" and filed paperwork to declare his candidacy this week, was among protesters at the coroner's office and the Center for Black Excellence and Culture. At a media briefing, he asked Crump whether there was a stab wound on the officer. Crump's answer — that Ozanne said there was no significant injury and the officer was not stabbed — provoked screams and chants of "Justice for Corey Ruiz" from the crowd. Hogoboom wrote that he has "serious concerns" about Ozanne's handling of the matter. "When conduct involving the use of force against Black men goes unprosecuted, it raises serious questions about accountability and the message that sends to law enforcement," he wrote.

Marcus Robert Johnson posted frequently on Facebook throughout the day, calling the charging decision "more than disappointing" and "absolutely abysmal." He was also spotted at the Center for Black Excellence and Culture. "The status quo wants to use moments like these in history to change the conversation. Do not let them," he wrote in another post.

Former Dane County Supervisor April Kigeya issued a statement calling on police agencies serving the Madison area — including the Madison Police Department, Dane County Sheriff's Department, UW Police, and Wisconsin State Patrol — to respect the First Amendment rights of activists protesting the decision. "When our institutions repeatedly fail to deliver accountability, they lose the public's trust," she wrote. "Madison has been here before. The city has repeatedly failed to address police violence, and unless something fundamentally changes, we risk seeing it happen again." Kigeya called for "truly independent, trusted police oversight in Madison."

Larry "Ace" Williams did not appear to issue a statement as of Friday morning.

Candidates will begin collecting signatures on nomination papers on Dec. 1.

More from The Madison Focal