Politics
Senate Confirms Colorado Judge Daniel Domenico to 10th Circuit Court of Appeals
The U.S. Senate voted 51-46 to elevate U.S. District Court Chief Judge Daniel Domenico to the Denver-based 10th Circuit, over objections from Colorado's Democratic senators about his immigration detention views and refusal to acknowledge Trump's 2020 loss.
The U.S. Senate on Monday confirmed U.S. District Court Chief Judge Daniel D. Domenico to a seat on the Denver-based U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit, voting 51-46 to elevate the Colorado jurist to the federal appellate bench.
Domenico, 54, becomes the only second-term appointee of President Donald Trump on the 10th Circuit, which hears federal appeals from Colorado, Oklahoma, Utah, Kansas, New Mexico and Wyoming. He succeeds Judge Timothy M. Tymkovich, a George W. Bush appointee who is taking senior status, a form of semi-retirement.
The confirmation drew opposition from both of Colorado's Democratic senators, Michael Bennet and John Hickenlooper. After Domenico's June hearing before the Senate Judiciary Committee, the two said they were troubled by his support for a broad reading of the government's immigration detention authority and by his refusal to acknowledge Trump's loss in the 2020 presidential election.
The 10th Circuit has 12 full-time judges, three of them from Colorado. Seven were appointed by Democratic presidents and five by Republicans. The court's clerk and circuit executive did not immediately respond to questions about when Domenico will be sworn in.
Domenico's elevation comes as Colorado's federal trial court struggles with an unprecedented caseload. With Trump's immigration policies driving a sharp increase in detentions, the district court is receiving roughly 100 petitions a week from people challenging the lawfulness of their confinement â an influx that has roughly doubled the court's caseload in a matter of months and strained both the court and the U.S. Attorney's Office.
Jeffrey P. Colwell, the court's clerk, said ideas are "in the works" to address a prolonged vacancy in one of the full-time district judge seats. "What we really need is more judges here full time that are on our bench to handle a caseload that continues to go up," he said. "But we are exploring other options as a temporary measure."
Colwell noted that the 10th Circuit can designate judges to other assignments within the six-state region. Tymkovich, for example, has occasionally handled cases in the trial court and in other circuit courts while serving as a full-time appellate judge.
Questions remain about how the state's district court vacancy will be filled. Hickenlooper's office said it had not decided whether to revive an advisory committee the senators used during the Biden administration to screen nominees for district court vacancies and propose finalists to the White House. Bennet's office did not respond. By tradition, senators have significant influence over district court nominations in their home states.
Colorado's district court has operated with its congressionally authorized seven full-time judges since 2024, though prolonged gaps have occurred across administrations. Domenico himself filled a vacancy in 2019 that had sat open for three years after the GOP-controlled Senate declined to vote on then-President Barack Obama's 2016 nominee.
Domenico graduated from Georgetown University and the University of Virginia's law school. After clerking for Tymkovich, he served as Colorado's solicitor general under Republican Attorney General John Suthers, arguing two cases before the U.S. Supreme Court and otherwise representing the state until entering private practice in 2015. He was interested in the 10th Circuit seat vacated by now-Justice Neil Gorsuch during Trump's first term, but Trump instead nominated him to the district court.
As a trial judge, Domenico handled several cases of high political significance. He blocked Colorado from enforcing a ban on "abortion reversal" treatment against a Catholic health clinic; required the state to accept a Christian preschool into its universal pre-kindergarten program despite conflicts with non-discrimination requirements; exempted two Denver-area churches from certain health restrictions early in the COVID-19 pandemic; and permitted a Castle Rock church to circumvent zoning restrictions for faith-based reasons.
Earlier this year, he became the only federal judge in Colorado to rule that the government may detain people in immigration custody without a bond hearing when they have been present in the country for years. The 10th Circuit decided shortly afterward that the government's understanding of its authority was incorrect.
Domenico briefly served as Colorado's chief district judge this year, stepping aside at the beginning of October in anticipation of his appellate confirmation. Across his two terms, Trump has appointed three members of the 10th Circuit, with Domenico joining Judges Allison H. Eid of Colorado and Joel M. Carson III of New Mexico.