Politics
Colorado Schools Told Not to Verify Student Sex Under New Transgender Athlete Law
State education officials issued guidance saying schools can trust students and families to comply with Proposition 134, which bars transgender athletes from teams matching their gender identity, without invasive physical or genetic checks. The directive sets up a clash with measure supporters and signals the legislature may revisit the law in January.
Colorado education officials on Wednesday told schools and districts they do not need to verify a student's sex to comply with Proposition 134, the ballot measure passed this month that bars transgender athletes from competing on school sports teams aligned with their gender identity.
The six-page guidance from the Colorado Department of Education, released about six weeks before the measure takes effect Jan. 1, explicitly prohibits schools from inspecting a student's body, requesting body photographs, asking for DNA or genetic testing, requiring physical exams to determine sex, demanding affidavits about a student's reproductive system, or questioning students about intimate medical information.
"A school or district may reasonably trust that students, parents, and guardians will comply with school or district policies," the guidance states. It adds that physical exams, genetic testing, parent affirmations, or medical documentation about a student's sex could violate students' constitutional rights and their right to be free from discrimination and harassment.
The directive frees schools from what had loomed as a contentious enforcement burden, but it is likely to anger backers of the measure, which passed 52-48%. While the ballot language did not specify how a student athlete's sex would be determined, supporters said during the campaign that cheek swab DNA testing or doctor's notes would be acceptable. They argued the measure was needed to protect girls' safety and opportunity in school sports.
Opponents countered that the measure would target a small and vulnerable population and subject both cisgender and transgender students to invasive gender checks. The share of transgender student athletes in school sports is exceedingly small.
Erin Lee, co-founder of Protect Kids Colorado, which advocated for Proposition 134, could not be reached for comment Wednesday.
Nadine Bridges, executive director of One Colorado, an LGBTQ advocacy group that opposed the measure, said the guidance makes clear that district policies should protect student privacy, avoid invasive checks, and comply with the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act, which bars discrimination based on characteristics including sexual orientation and gender identity.
"What I'm feeling is that we have more work to do," Bridges said over text. "I hope that our schools will focus on creating healthy environments for all students to thrive in."
The guidance does require schools and districts to pass policies designating sports teams as male, female, and co-ed. Girls teams should not be open to males and boys teams should not be open to females, except when there is no girls team in that sport, according to the document. But it also says schools do not have to change existing practices related to sports physicals, records, or registration.
The guidance acknowledges that questions about the ballot measure remain and may be resolved through lawsuits or legislative changes. Gov.-elect Phil Weiser and other state lawmakers have described Proposition 134 as problematic and suggested the legislature will make changes during the 2027 session, which starts in January. Democrats hold supermajorities in both chambers.
Supporters of Proposition 134 have already started a petition pushing back against any potential legislative changes.
The guidance represents a significant interpretation of the new law by state officials, who are signaling they will not enforce it in the way supporters envisioned. For schools, it means they can avoid invasive verification procedures while still requiring policies that separate teams by sex. For families, it offers reassurance that students will not be subjected to body inspections or genetic tests to play sports.
The coming months are likely to bring legal challenges and political fights as the legislature, governor-elect, and advocacy groups on both sides seek to shape how Proposition 134 is implemented.