Friday, November 20, 2026·Focal News

The Denver Focal

Denver's independent voice

Politics

Advance Colorado Sues to Overturn Voter-Approved Graduated Income Tax, Alleges TABOR Violations

A conservative group filed suit on behalf of two Republican senators against Amendment 87, arguing the measure unconstitutionally bundled constitutional changes with statutory tax rates and that the state's voter guide misstated its fiscal impact. The group also filed countermeasures for 2027, including a proposal to zero out taxes on the first $100,000 of income.

Advance Colorado Sues to Overturn Voter-Approved Graduated Income Tax, Alleges TABOR Violations

A Colorado advocacy group has filed a lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of Amendment 87, the graduated income tax measure that voters approved just two weeks ago, alleging the ballot question violated the state's Taxpayer's Bill of Rights by combining constitutional amendments with statutory tax rate changes in a single measure.

Advance Colorado filed the suit on behalf of Republican Sens. Barb Kirkmeyer of Brighton and Byron Pelton of Sterling. The complaint argues that Amendment 87 improperly bundled multiple constitutional changes with new statutory tax rates, violating TABOR's prohibition on consolidating constitutional amendments with statutory provisions.

"Whether or not the measure satisfied the single-subject rule, TABOR's separate prohibition on consolidating constitutional amendments with statutory rate increases required Amendment 87 to be split and presented to the people as two separate measures," the lawsuit states. It points to the 2005 precedent of Referendum C and Referendum D, which the General Assembly presented as separate questions even though D was contingent on C.

Amendment 87, backed by a coalition of more than 100 nonprofit organizations, passed with 51.72% of the vote. It raises taxes on income above $500,000 and lowers liability for earners below that threshold. Supporters framed the vote as a long-overdue correction to a tax code they said had working families paying the same rate as the most profitable corporations.

"This is the most significant change to Colorado's fiscal policy in at least 20 years," Chris deGruy Kennedy, co-chair of Protect Colorado's Future and president of the Bell Policy Center, said at a post-election rally. He called the result "a signal by voters that we are fundamentally changing the direction of how we are going to make sure Colorado's economy supports every hardworking person, every older adult, every child and everyone in between."

The coalition behind the amendment said in a statement that its work now is to ensure the measure delivers on its promises of support for schools, health care and child care.

The lawsuit also takes aim at the state's ballot information booklet, known as the Blue Book, accusing it of containing "objectively false information" about Amendment 87's fiscal impact. According to the complaint, the Blue Book applied graduated rates to income that had already been apportioned to Colorado, reversing the order of operations required by state law, Department of Revenue regulations and the amendment's own text.

That methodological error, the suit alleges, told voters in the $500,000 to $1 million bracket they would receive an average tax cut of $284, when the correct calculation would have shown an average increase of roughly $2,651. The complaint says the error distorted nine of the 12 income brackets and misstated the overall fiscal impact by about $1.2 billion.

The lawsuit further alleges the Blue Book promised the measure would increase available state funding for school districts, but that Gov. Jared Polis has acknowledged at a Joint Budget Committee meeting that within three years the revenue "all goes to Medicaid." Polis has warned lawmakers that Medicaid costs threaten the rest of the budget for the 2027-28 fiscal year, saying without changes "there's no money left for education or roads or anything else."

"It's clear that Amendment 87 should have been filed as two measures, not a single one," Kirkmeyer said in a news release. "The constitution wasn't followed, and voters will pay the price if this measure isn't overturned."

Advance Colorado also filed several countermeasures for the 2027 election, including one that would set the tax rate on the first $100,000 of income to zero and tax income above that at 4.4%, creating a two-rate system in place of Amendment 87's multiple tiers.

"This state is simply too unaffordable for too many Coloradans," said Advance Colorado President Michael Fields. "When people see the economic destruction that Amendment 87 will cause, they will want immediate reform. Exempting the first $100k of income for individuals and businesses will make Colorado more competitive and will put more money in people's pockets."

The group had previously run a countermeasure in this year's election that would have capped the state income tax at its current 4.4% rate; that measure failed.

The legal challenge sets up a high-stakes fight over the future of Colorado's tax structure and the revenue stream that supporters say is essential to funding schools, health care and child care. A court ruling against the amendment would erase the new revenue and return the state to a flat tax, while a ruling in its favor would cement one of the most significant fiscal changes in a generation.

More from The Denver Focal