Politics
Federal Judge Allows Narrowed Second Amendment Challenge to Colorado Gun Permit Law
A federal judge in Denver dismissed a broad challenge to Colorado's 2025 permit-to-purchase law for semiautomatic firearms but allowed four individual plaintiffs to argue the law is unconstitutional as applied to them. The judge also fully dismissed a challenge to the state's ban on rapid-fire devices, ruling they are not protected 'arms' under the Second Amendment.
A federal judge in Denver has narrowed a Second Amendment lawsuit against Colorado's 2025 permit-to-purchase law, allowing a scaled-back version of the challenge to proceed while dismissing claims that the entire framework and a separate ban on rapid-fire devices are unconstitutional.
U.S. District Court Senior Judge William J. MartÃnez issued the ruling on Nov. 18 in the case Del Toro et al. v. Polis et al., brought by five individual Coloradans and the Colorado State Shooting Association. The plaintiffs challenged Senate Bill 003, enacted last year, which requires purchasers of certain semiautomatic firearms to complete training, pass an exam, and obtain authorization from county sheriffs before buying a weapon.
In a Nov. 5 order, MartÃnez declined to block the permit-to-purchase framework, finding the plaintiffs were unlikely to prove a constitutional violation. In his follow-up order on the state's motion to dismiss, the judge stood by that analysis, reiterating that the U.S. Supreme Court has upheld 'shall-issue' licensing regimes and that SB 003 created such a process.
'Therefore, Plaintiffs challenge must do more than allege that the regime burdens the Second Amendment,' wrote MartÃnez, an appointee of former President Barack Obama. 'Plaintiffs must plausibly allege that the scheme is put towards