Politics
Colorado Appeals Court Overturns Wildlife Rules, Faults Agency for Ignoring Public Comments
A three-judge panel found Colorado Parks and Wildlife violated the Administrative Procedure Act by inviting public feedback on a website and then disregarding nearly 200 comments, most of which opposed the proposed rules. The ruling vacates the 2023 regulations and sends the case back to district court.
A Colorado Court of Appeals panel has overturned a set of 2023 Colorado Parks and Wildlife regulations after finding the agency solicited public feedback through a website it promoted, then failed to consider the vast majority of comments submitted there. The unanimous three-judge ruling, issued November 19, found that CPW violated the state's Administrative Procedure Act and ordered the rules vacated.
The case, Friends of Animals v. Colorado Parks and Wildlife Commission, centered on regulations governing recreational activities in state wildlife areas. According to the opinion authored by Judge Grant T. Sullivan, CPW published three official notices encouraging written comments to the commission's email address. But the agency also issued a press release directing the public to "learn more and provide feedback on EngageCPW," a website that stated comments would be "reviewed by CPW staff and considered by the Parks and Wildlife Commission."
The response was lopsided. CPW received 191 comments through EngageCPW and just seven via email. Roughly 75% of the EngageCPW submissions opposed the rule changes. Rather than including the comments in the rulemaking record, agency staff summarized them in a 2.5-page memo provided to commissioners, and the commission subsequently approved the new rules.
"CPW created a process that thwarted fully informed agency decision-making and lacked transparency," Sullivan wrote. "Equally troubling, CPW's process actively misled a large swath of the public participants into believing that the Commission would consider their comments, preventing those participants from providing input into the final rules."
Conservation and environmental groups challenged the rules in Denver District Court. Chief Judge Christopher J. Baumann upheld the agency's action, finding that CPW had "substantially complied" with its public comment obligations because commissioners received a summary of the comments and because email submissions were properly considered. Baumann acknowledged the press release "seemed to generate a fair amount of confusion" but concluded the agency had met its statutory duty.
The appeals panel disagreed. During oral arguments, Judge Jerry N. Jones pressed Senior Assistant Attorney General Christopher R. Stork on whether the agency believed it could disregard comments submitted outside the formal notice process. "With all due respect, I don't see anywhere in the APA that says if you give official notice, you don't have to consider anything else," Jones said. Judge Karl L. Schock asked whether the commission was taking the position that it could have ignored the comments because they were submitted outside the official process, and Sullivan questioned whether overlooking the 191 comments was a mistake or a deliberate choice. Stork acknowledged "there was an irregularity" that "caused confusion."
In its ruling, the panel held that the Administrative Procedure Act requires the agency record to include "any written comments" and that CPW's failure to consider the EngageCPW submissions was a clear violation. Sullivan noted that the "sheer volume" of opposition might have changed the outcome had commissioners reviewed the comments directly. "In short, CPW's noncompliance was extensive," he wrote.
The panel returned the case to Baumann with instructions to vacate the regulations. The decision underscores the legal weight of public participation in agency rulemaking and raises questions about how state agencies solicit and process public input, particularly when they direct residents to online platforms that may not feed directly into the formal decision-making record.