Politics
Colorado Appeals Court Upholds 2023 Car Theft Law, Rejecting Equal Protection Challenge
A three-judge panel ruled 3-0 that a 2023 law making prior vehicle theft convictions an element of first-degree motor vehicle theft does not violate equal protection, rejecting a convicted Adams County man's claim that jurors should not have heard about his past convictions during trial.
DENVER â Colorado's second-highest court has rejected a constitutional challenge to the state's 2023 motor vehicle theft law, ruling that lawmakers acted within their authority when they made prior theft convictions an element of the crime rather than a sentencing enhancement.
A three-judge panel of the Colorado Court of Appeals voted 3-0 on Nov. 19 to uphold the conviction of Rudy Levi Hurtado, who was found guilty of first-degree motor vehicle theft by an Adams County jury in 2024. Judge Stephanie Dunn authored the opinion, joined by Judges Timothy J. Schutz and Kyle Brenton.
The case centered on a change lawmakers made in 2023 through Senate Bill 23-097. Previously, penalties for motor vehicle theft were based on the value of the stolen vehicle. Under the new framework, the crime becomes a more severe felony if a defendant has prior vehicle theft convictions.
Hurtado's defense attorney, Lindsey Parlin, argued that the law violated her client's right to equal protection under the constitution. She contended that allowing jurors to hear evidence of Hurtado's prior convictions at the same time they considered his current charge was unfairly prejudicial. Parlin had asked the trial judge to bifurcate the proceedings â meaning jurors would first decide whether Hurtado committed the current offense, then hear evidence about his prior convictions â but the request was denied.
"Over and over again, the jury was reminded of Mr. Hurtado's history of being convicted of motor vehicle theft," Parlin wrote in her appeal. "There was no way to ensure that the jury did not actually convict him because it knew he had multiple prior convictions for motor vehicle theft."
Parlin compared the vehicle theft statute to Colorado's animal cruelty law, which treats prior convictions as a sentence enhancer proven later to a judge rather than as an element of the crime that a jury must consider. She argued there was no legitimate legislative purpose for treating the two offenses differently.
The appeals panel disagreed, noting that the two laws address "entirely different conduct."
"Hurtado's real grievance seems to be with the legislature's decision to make the fact of prior convictions an element of first degree motor vehicle theft rather than a sentence enhancer," Dunn wrote. "But the legislature alone has the 'power to define criminal conduct and to establish the legal components of criminal liability.'"
Dunn acknowledged that having jurors hear about a defendant's prior convictions for the same offense at the same time they hear about the charged conduct was "a valid concern." But she said it was not one the Equal Protection Clauses are designed to remedy.
"Equal protection concerns the differential treatment of similarly situated individuals," Dunn wrote. "And the legislative choice to treat the fact of prior convictions differently in two separate statutes addressing different crimes doesn't violate Hurtado's equal protection rights."
The ruling is the latest interpretation of a law that has reshaped how Colorado prosecutes repeat vehicle theft offenders. By making prior convictions an element of first-degree motor vehicle theft, the statute requires prosecutors to prove those convictions to a jury beyond a reasonable doubt â a higher bar than the pre-2023 system, in which prior convictions could be used to increase sentences after a guilty verdict.
The decision in People v. Hurtado was issued Nov. 19, 2026.