Thursday, November 19, 2026·Focal News

The Chicago Focal

Chicago's independent voice

Politics

Chicago City Council Votes for Independent Probe of City Finances After CFO's Resignation

Aldermen voted 45-5 to hire an outside firm to investigate whether the city misled investors and the public about its financial health, following the abrupt resignation of CFO Ashlee Gabrysch and a negative credit watch from S&P.

Chicago City Council Votes for Independent Probe of City Finances After CFO's Resignation

CHICAGO — The City Council voted 45-5 on Wednesday to launch an independent investigation into whether the city has made misleading statements about its finances, following the resignation last week of Chief Financial Officer Ashlee Gabrysch, the third person to hold that post this year.

The ordinance authorizes Finance Committee Chair Ald. Pat Dowell to hire an outside firm to review three years of city finances, focusing on "whether any material or intentional misstatements" were made to investors, council members or the public. The measure cites concerns about "integrity, transparency, accuracy and honesty."

Gabrysch, who served only three months, said in her resignation letter that staying on would "compromise my integrity and professional obligations." Her departure sent shockwaves through the council and intensified scrutiny of Mayor Brandon Johnson's fiscal management.

"The taxpayers, the bond rating agencies: They want to know what's going on," said Ald. Matt O'Shea (19th Ward). "And we owe it to the taxpayers to lift up the hood, see what's going on and who knew what, what they knew about it, what they did about it."

The vote came after a heated special meeting. Ald. Brendan Reilly (42nd Ward) stressed that the probe is not a standard audit. "There will be a review of emails, memos, conversations that were had, presentations that have been made, draft PowerPoints on how this budget has been characterized and how the city's financial position has been represented to make sure that those things are accurate, and that there hasn't been an effort to obfuscate or hide the facts," Reilly said.

Ald. Andre Vasquez (40th Ward) echoed the public's eroding trust. "You know what people are saying? That they don't trust city government, and they don't trust us with the funds," he said.

Mayor Johnson's office issued a statement saying the administration "welcomes an independent audit of the City's finances in accordance with professionally accepted standards for municipal finance." But several aldermen rejected that characterization, insisting the review goes beyond a traditional audit.

Not everyone supported the investigation. Ald. Jason Ervin (28th Ward), one of five "No" votes, called it "a waste of taxpayer money" and "a waste of resources," adding that it stems from "somebody made a mistake in trying to backtrack and cover it up."

The dispute centers on a fundamental disagreement over how to characterize the city's budget. Johnson has said next year's budget is 76% structural, meaning it relies on recurring revenue rather than one-time fixes. Gabrysch publicly countered that it is only 56% structural because she believes borrowing to cover police misconduct settlements does not count as structural revenue.

"Taking out a credit card to pay for something isn't revenue. It is financing. It is borrowing. It is not revenue," Vasquez said.

The investigation is expected to be completed before the year-end budget deadline. Dowell also wants Gabrysch to answer questions publicly.

On the same day as the council vote, S&P Global Ratings placed the city on CreditWatch Negative, signaling an increased likelihood of a credit downgrade within 90 days. The agency cited "the current budget stalemate" and said negotiations appear to be "heading down a path similar to that of the past two years."

S&P warned that a negative rating action is likely if the enacted fiscal 2027 budget "relies too heavily on unsustainable solutions to close the gap, perpetuating the city's chronic reliance on short-term expedients that reduce fiscal resilience." The agency also noted that Gabrysch's exit "comes at a critical juncture" and that management turnover adds to the city's immediate challenges.

Mayor Johnson responded to S&P's announcement with a statement calling the warning "a sobering reminder of our collective obligation to the residents of this city that we must work together toward constructive solutions." He urged the council to "lower our voices and raise our sights" and noted that passing a balanced budget would alleviate S&P's concerns. Johnson also said the city has identified $860 million in savings and efficiencies over the past three years, including $60 million in the fiscal 2027 budget informed by Ernst & Young recommendations.

Acting CFO and Comptroller Michael Belsky, a 35-year veteran of municipal finance, said the CreditWatch notice is "a caution about market concerns and to offer an opportunity to remedy those concerns." He emphasized that the city can avoid a downgrade by promptly passing a balanced budget built on structural revenue solutions, and he defended the mayor's proposed "Fair Share Budget" as structurally sound. Belsky also clarified that the CFO is primarily responsible for debt management and public-private partnerships, while more than 675 employees in the Office of Budget and Management and the Department of Finance handle the city's fiscal responsibilities.

The investigation will be conducted by an outside firm yet to be selected. The council aims to complete the review before the Dec. 31 statutory deadline for budget passage.

More from The Chicago Focal