Politics
S&P Puts Chicago on CreditWatch, Warning of Possible Downgrade Within 90 Days
Standard & Poor's placed Chicago on CreditWatch with negative implications, citing the abrupt resignation of CFO Ashlee Gabrysch and a budget stalemate that leaves the city's BBB rating just two notches above junk. The agency warned there is at least a one-in-two chance of a downgrade within 90 days unless the 2027 budget relies on structural fixes.
Standard & Poor's on Wednesday placed Chicago on CreditWatch with negative implications, reaffirming the city's BBB general obligation bond rating but warning that a downgrade is possible within 90 days. The rating stands just two notches above junk status.
The action follows last week's abrupt resignation of Chief Financial Officer Ashlee Gabrysch, the city's third CFO in a year, and comes amid an ongoing budget stalemate between Mayor Brandon Johnson and a majority of the City Council over the mayor's proposed $17.6 billion spending plan.
S&P said there is "at least a one-in-two chance of a downgrade in the next 90 days," depending on whether the 2027 budget makes progress toward reducing the city's structural deficit. The agency cited the budget impasse and what it described as a pattern of management instability.
"The CreditWatch placement reflects our view of the elevated likelihood of a negative rating action ... given the current budget stalemate and given that budget negotiations during this critical period appear to be heading down a path similar to that of the past two years," S&P wrote, adding that the city may again resort to "significant one-time measures" to balance the budget.
Gabrysch resigned after an internal dispute over the size of the structural deficit, writing that continuing in the role "would be to compromise my integrity and professional obligation." S&P said her departure continues "a string of high-profile management departures over the past year that, at this stage, we believe constitutes a pattern of management instability that injects added uncertainty into the budget process."
The agency also noted that a majority of the City Council recently signed a letter rejecting more than $400 million in revenue proposals in the mayor's budget, including a $75 million upfront payment from the New York investment firm that acquired Chicago's parking meters, more than $100 million from a revived corporate head tax, and $234 million from a 33% increase in the city's tax on cloud computing and equipment leasing.
S&P concluded that most of the measures Johnson has used to close an $882 million gap in the corporate fund are "either non-structural or contested by a City Council majority," and that spending cuts are "significantly limited" in the mayor's plan.
Johnson responded that the warning is a "sobering reminder of our collective obligation to the residents of this city" and called for "good-faith dialogue." He said the rating agency "specifically cautions about the risks of an artificial gridlock as a major driver of their concern," and argued that passing a budget would alleviate those concerns. The mayor also said it is "disheartening that segments of the City Council have rejected more than $400 million in structural revenues."
The council coalition that opposes the mayor's business taxes said it sent Johnson a roadmap seven weeks ago for a passable budget and that he has "done nothing" since but "point fingers and divide" Chicagoans. "This is a crisis of his own making â a one-way staring contest that threatens our city's financial future," the group said, calling the CreditWatch action "a shot across the bow to the one person whose job it is to put forth a responsible, passable budget."
Acting CFO Michael Belsky said the purpose of the CreditWatch is to elevate market concerns and give the city an opportunity to address them. "The city can avoid a downgrade by promptly passing a balanced budget built upon structural revenue solutions," he said.
A downgrade would raise borrowing costs for the city and further strain a budget already under pressure. The warning puts new urgency on negotiations with roughly six weeks left before the budget deadline.