Politics
Chicago City Council Unanimously Backs Millionaire Tax Referendum, but Infighting Erupts Over 'Hypocrisy'
The Chicago City Council passed a non-binding resolution urging state lawmakers to place a constitutional amendment on the ballot to tax incomes over $1 million, but the vote exposed deep divisions over Mayor Brandon Johnson's broader tax-the-rich agenda, with supporters accusing the resolution's sponsors of political posturing.
The Chicago City Council on Wednesday unanimously approved a resolution calling on the Illinois General Assembly to put a binding constitutional amendment on the ballot that would authorize a tax on individual incomes over $1 million. The vote, while unanimous, was preceded by sharp exchanges that laid bare a rift within the Council over howâand whetherâto raise revenue from the wealthy.
The resolution, introduced by a group of alderpersons who have opposed Mayor Brandon Johnson's proposed corporate head tax, urges state lawmakers to act. But Johnson's Council allies accused the resolution's sponsors of hypocrisy, arguing that they are eager to tax the rich at the state level while blocking similar efforts at home.
"I am at a loss right now trying to wrap my head around the hypocrisy of this introduction from people who have been completely opposed to taxing the rich and are passing the buck to the state," said Ald. Rosanna Rodriguez-Sanchez (33rd), one of the mayor's most vocal supporters. "It is wild to me that we have literally a budget proposal that calls for taxing wealthy corporations in Chicago. ⦠This is an opportunistic attempt to brand themselves as progressive without actually having to do it."
Ald. Byron Sigcho-Lopez (25th) was even more blunt, laughing as he said, "the hypocrisy is just laughable." He urged his colleagues to "leave the theater and the theatrics out of this" and to put their political muscle behind the effort. "Who's gonna go to Springfield now that we are so courageous? ... Let's put action into this resolution," he said.
The tension stems from a broader budget fight. Twenty-eight alderpersons have declared their opposition to more than $400 million of the mayor's proposed tax increases, including a revived head tax on large employers. That tax, which Johnson has championed, would charge businesses with more than 125 employees $25 per employee per month. Critics argue it would drive jobs out of the city.
Ald. Michelle Harris (8th) defended the distinction between the millionaire tax and the head tax. "Taxes on jobs is a killer. It will kill our economy. It will kill our city. And it's the fastest way to get big businesses to leave our city, take their jobs, run away and take them to communities all outside the city," she said.
Ald. Gilbert Villegas (36th), chair of the Zoning Committee, said the Council's "hands are tied" on the millionaire tax and that state action is necessary. He argued the resolution "outlines concrete action items to get the wealthy to pay their fair share," unlike what he characterized as the mayor's empty rhetoric.
Mayor Johnson has challenged his critics to propose alternative revenue sources, though they insist the onus is on him to find a balanced budget. The city faces significant fiscal pressures, with a budget gap that could worsen next year.
Ald. Jesse Fuentes (26th) urged her colleagues to tone down the attacks. "This is an easy vote. ⦠But, I want to caution us throwing daggers at each other at this moment," she said. "We need each other to pass this budget. We got some budget woesâand they'll be worse next year. And so, while I believe in the progressive revenue in the proposed budget, I'm not gonna shoot an arrow at the folks that are skeptical right now."
The resolution is non-binding and does not itself enact a tax. It simply expresses the Council's support for a state constitutional amendment, which would require approval by the General Assembly and then by voters in a statewide referendum. Similar proposals have been floated in Springfield in recent years but have failed to gain traction. Supporters say the measure would generate billions in new revenue for schools and local governments, while opponents warn it would drive high earners out of Illinois.
The Council's action comes as the city grapples with a projected budget shortfall and as the mayor's relationship with a bloc of aldermen remains strained. The unanimous vote on the resolution masks the underlying disagreement over how to address the city's fiscal challengesâand who should bear the burden.