Local
Illinois Approved AHS Takeover of Waukegan Hospital Despite Red Flags at Its Granite City Facility
New documents show Illinois regulators unanimously approved American Healthcare Systems' 2023 purchase of Vista Medical Center East even as another AHS hospital in Granite City was losing its safety grade and employees' health coverage. Now Vista is in crisis, and officials want AHS to sell.
WAUKEGAN, Ill. â When for-profit hospital operator American Healthcare Systems took over Vista Medical Center East in July 2023, it promised a fresh start for a financially struggling hospital serving Waukegan and surrounding Lake County communities. But a review of public records shows that state regulators approved the deal even as serious problems were emerging at another Illinois hospital owned by the same company.
The Illinois Health Facilities and Services Review Board voted 8-0 in June 2023 to approve AHS's acquisition of Vista, which had been losing more than $4 million annually on patient services. The deal had support from then-Waukegan Mayor Ann Taylor and State Sen. Adriane Johnson, who both submitted letters endorsing the company's commitment to preserve services and retain employees.
Yet in the months before that vote, warning signs were already visible at Gateway Regional Medical Center in Granite City, another AHS-owned hospital. In May 2023, the Leapfrog Group, a hospital safety watchdog, gave Gateway a D safety grade, reflecting below-average performance on infection prevention, medication administration and staffing, according to reporting by the Belleville News-Democrat.
On June 9, 2023, Gateway employees were told their health insurance had been canceled effective June 1. But a memo from the hospital's benefits provider, Modern HR, said coverage had actually been terminated April 30 because Gateway and its parent company had failed to pay outstanding payroll and benefits obligations.
Those developments unfolded as AHS pursued the Vista acquisition. Illinois held a public hearing on the proposed transaction on June 12, 2023. Eight days later, The Telegraph published an investigation into Gateway's employee health insurance problems and allegations of unpaid compensation and benefits. On June 27, the review board voted unanimously to approve the Vista deal.
A transcript of the public meeting reviewed by NBC 5 Investigates shows no mention of the issues at Gateway. It remains unclear whether board members were aware of the problems or whether they were considered during the approval process. Neither the Illinois Health Facilities and Services Review Board nor American Healthcare Systems responded to requests for comment. As of Tuesday, Nov. 17, the company's website was not operational.
Now, Vista is facing what local officials describe as a deepening financial and operational crisis. Employees say they are still waiting to be paid, and state and local leaders are calling on AHS to relinquish control of the hospital. The situation has raised questions about how the state vets hospital operators and whether the warning signs at Gateway should have prompted closer scrutiny before the Vista deal was approved.
For Waukegan residents, Vista is the city's only hospital, and its troubles have far-reaching consequences for access to care in Lake County. The hospital recently lost its trauma center designation, and its maternity and OB-GYN services were slated to shut down, according to city officials. The unfolding crisis has left community members and local leaders demanding accountability from both the company and the state regulators who greenlit the takeover.