Local
Cook County Judge Overturns Anthony Garrett's 1994 Murder Conviction in Dantrell Davis Case, Citing Tortured Confession
A Cook County judge on Monday vacated Anthony Garrett's conviction in the 1992 killing of 7-year-old Dantrell Davis, finding that his confession was likely tortured out of him by a Chicago detective with a history of abuse allegations, including at Guantánamo Bay.
A Cook County judge on Monday threw out the murder conviction of Anthony Garrett in the 1992 killing of 7-year-old Dantrell Davis, ruling that Garrett's handwritten confession was likely coerced through torture by a now-retired Chicago police detective.
Circuit Judge Adrienne E. Davis issued a 37-page written order and announced from the bench at the Leighton Criminal Courthouse that she found the testimony of Richard Zuley, 80, "not credible." The judge vacated Garrett's conviction and sentence, suppressed his handwritten statement, ordered a retrial, and directed that Garrett be transferred from state prison to Cook County Jail.
Garrett, 68, wept as the judge read her ruling, according to his attorneys. More than a dozen friends and relatives in the courtroom were elated. His daughter, Tamika Henderson, who was 9 years old when her father was arrested, said after the hearing, "I just feel so much joy inside. I'm holding back tears. This is wonderful. It has been a long time coming."
Henderson said the case's effects on her life include her last name, which her maternal grandmother changed from Garrett after the arrest. The family called on State's Attorney Eileen O'Neill Burke's office to drop the charges.
Linda Walls, who heads the office's post-conviction unit, indicated prosecutors might appeal the ruling but declined to comment outside the courtroom. O'Neill Burke's office said in a statement, "We are currently reviewing the court's ruling to determine the next legal steps."
Garrett's attorneys asked for his release from custody. Judge Davis scheduled a Dec. 7 hearing on that request and the possible appeal.
In her ruling, Davis said there was a preponderance of evidence that officers at the Chicago Police Department's former Area 6 detective station beat Garrett's confession out of him, and that introducing that confession at trial violated his due-process rights. However, Davis denied Garrett's claim that prosecutors violated his rights by failing to turn over evidence that Zuley had a "pattern and practice" of torture, and she also denied his claim that this evidence proved his actual innocence.
"Our biggest hopes were to win on the claims that we won on," said Jennifer Blagg, Garrett's lead attorney. "So we are very happy with the ruling."
The decision followed an evidentiary hearing that spanned six months and ended in May. Blagg tied Garrett's alleged torture to Zuley-led coercion in a string of cases from 1987 to 2003, including four murder convictions later thrown out. She also likened Garrett's treatment to torture when Zuley was a U.S. Naval reservist at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba, recounting testimony last November by Mohamedou Ould Slahi, who appeared via Zoom from Rotterdam.
Slahi, a Sept. 11 terror suspect, alleged Zuley subjected him to months of torture in 2003 at the detention camp. Slahi, 55, wrote a memoir about the experience that formed the basis of a 2021 film drama starring Jodie Foster and Benedict Cumberbatch. "The real Dick Zuley, I would submit to the court, is the one Mohamedou Ould Slahi saw," Blagg said in her closing argument.
Prosecutors urged Davis to disregard claims against Zuley in other cases. Armando G. Sandoval, one of the prosecutors, called them "allegations, not findings" and said they had "no connection to Garrett." He also cast doubt on Garrett's account that two large men wearing sports jerseys beat him at Zuley's behest while he was shackled to an eyebolt, focusing blows on a leg where physicians had implanted a rod after a gunshot wound. Sandoval pointed to testimony that Garrett was not limping after his interrogation and noted that Garrett's initial claim involved a rubber hose, later changed to include a phone book. "His account shifts," Sandoval said. "That's important."
Dantrell Davis was killed on Oct. 13, 1992, as he walked to school with his mother in Cabrini-Green, a former North Side public housing complex. Police said a sniper shot him from an upper floor of a building. Garrett was convicted by a jury in 1994 and sentenced to 100 years in prison. He is held at downstate Centralia Correctional Center and is not scheduled for release until 2039, according to the Illinois Department of Corrections.
In 2023, an Illinois Torture and Relief Commission finding detailed an "overwhelming" history of "lengthy and consistent" complaints alleging psychological and physical torture involving Zuley, who was hired by the police department in 1970 and worked more than three decades for the department.
Slahi, who knew Zuley as "Capt. Collins," testified that the detective led "enhanced interrogation techniques," including isolation, temperature extremes, beatings, sexual humiliation, sleep deprivation, waterboarding, barking dogs, a mock execution at sea, and round-the-clock mistreatment with strobe lights and a looped recording of the U.S. national anthem. After 70 days of torture, Slahi testified, the detective convinced him U.S. authorities were allowing his mother to be kidnapped and raped. Slahi admitted he never saw Zuley lay a hand on him but added that he wouldn't know because he was usually blindfolded. Slahi was held at Guantánamo for 14 years without charges before he was released to his native Mauritania in 2016.
Zuley testified in February and April, denying he knew of anyone handcuffing Garrett to the eyebolt or subjecting him to physical or mental abuse. He said he left other detectives in charge of Garrett overnight, and the next morning Garrett confessed to shooting at members of a rival gang near Dantrell. Zuley said threats and physical abuse were less reliable than "rapport building" for extracting information from suspects.
Judges have vacated at least four murder convictions involving Zuley. The exonerees are Lathierial Boyd, Lee Harris, Carl Reed and David Wright. President Donald Trump's administration blocked Garrett's attorneys from questioning Zuley about his work at Guantánamo.