Tuesday, November 17, 2026·Focal News

The Chicago Focal

Chicago's independent voice

Local

Cook County Jail Wrongful Death Settlement Reaches Record $7.25 Million as Calls for Independent Oversight Grow

The family of Cory Ulmer, a 41-year-old man with mental illness who died after being beaten by correctional officers at Cook County Jail in 2024, has agreed to a $7.25 million settlement—the largest jail-related payout in nearly two decades. The deal comes amid mounting demands for independent monitoring of the jail and scrutiny of Sheriff Tom Dart's office.

Cook County Jail Wrongful Death Settlement Reaches Record $7.25 Million as Calls for Independent Oversight Grow

The family of a man with mental illness who died after being beaten by correctional officers at the Cook County Jail has agreed to settle a wrongful death lawsuit for $7.25 million, a payout that would be the county's largest for a jail-related case since at least 2007.

The Cook County Board of Commissioners' Finance Committee is scheduled to vote Wednesday on the settlement, which would resolve a federal lawsuit filed by Robert Robinson, the stepfather of 41-year-old Cory Ulmer. If approved by the full board, the deal would dismiss the county from the litigation.

Ulmer died in June 2024, a day after he was taken into custody for violating a court-ordered curfew related to 2023 assault and armed robbery charges. Records show arresting officers with the sheriff's electronic monitoring unit noted Ulmer appeared unwell—walking shirtless on a road after midnight—and one speculated he was "off his meds." The officers considered taking him home or to a hospital but brought him to the jail instead.

Once inside, Ulmer was placed in a basement holding cell known as a "bullpen," where he remained for at least 24 hours awaiting transfer to a psychiatric unit. After he tried to run out of the small, bedless cell, officers struck him repeatedly, according to an internal report leaked to Injustice Watch days after his death. Witnesses told investigators that officers dragged Ulmer into the jail's emergency room and kicked, punched, and kneed him as he lay facedown and shackled, facing away from security cameras. He was then injected with sedatives, became unresponsive, and was pronounced dead at Mount Sinai Hospital. The Cook County medical examiner ruled his death a homicide.

The sheriff's office initially told Ulmer's family only that he died following a medical emergency.

An internal investigation closed in December 2025 found that several officers committed misconduct. Investigators recommended termination for Sgt. Enrique Reyes and correctional officer Jason Jackson. A medical staff member who witnessed the beating told investigators that Jackson struck Ulmer the most, including kicking him in the head multiple times. Investigators also found that Reyes told medical staff to leave the area and turned off his body-worn camera during the incident. Reyes claimed he turned off the camera because Ulmer was about to receive medical attention, but investigators determined that was untrue.

Jackson's firing is now before the sheriff's Merit Board, a seven-member body appointed by Dart and approved by county commissioners. Reyes' termination is in arbitration under the correctional sergeant's union contract. Both have been stripped of police powers and assigned to warehouse work.

Records show both officers had been investigated for misconduct before Ulmer's death. Jackson was recommended for firing in 2017, a year after he was hired, for allowing detainees to enter a visiting area without permission and failing to stop them from masturbating in view of visitors. An arbitrator instead reinstated him after a six-month suspension. The sheriff's office said it considered the unpaid suspension appropriate discipline and did not pursue further action. Jackson was later found to have committed misconduct in four additional disciplinary cases.

Reyes was investigated for excessive force in 2012, 2013, 2014, and 2021, and for failing to follow policy in 2023. Investigators either exonerated him, closed the cases without a disposition, or did not sustain the allegations.

Six other officers face suspensions ranging from 45 to 120 days for using unnecessary force and being untruthful to investigators, among other violations. So far, only one officer has served a suspension, which an arbitrator reduced from 45 days to five. The rest remain in arbitration.

Of the 11 medical staff named in the lawsuit, one has left the jail; the others, including doctors, nurses, and mental health specialists, continued working there as of late October. A spokesperson for Cermak Health Services, the jail's healthcare provider, did not say whether any had been disciplined.

Dart's internal investigators did not examine why jail officials failed to notify the Cook County medical examiner when Ulmer died. Under county code, law enforcement must notify the medical examiner "immediately" upon a death in custody. Instead, a Mount Sinai nurse notified the medical examiner nearly six hours after Ulmer was pronounced dead—by which time the jail's emergency room had been cleaned.

In a statement, Robinson's attorney, Jesse Guth, said there was "no excuse for the brutality that Cory suffered" and called on lawmakers to open the jail to independent monitoring. "History will continue to repeat itself until changes are implemented," Guth said.

Dart, who won another four-year term in this month's general election, declined to be interviewed, citing pending litigation. Dr. Priscilla Ware, medical director of Cermak Health Services, also declined. Ware was not a defendant in the lawsuit.

The settlement vote comes as advocates and some county commissioners push for greater oversight of the jail. Currently, the only external monitoring is conducted by the Illinois Department of Corrections' jail and detention standards unit, which inspects the facility annually. State inspectors have cited the jail for violations in six of the past nine years, including every year since 2022, according to reporting by the Illinois Answers Project. In 2025, inspectors found violations related to supervision, security, admissions procedures, reporting, and sanitation.

"Obviously, four years in a row of failed inspections, the accountability is not there," said Matthew McLoughlin, a campaign coordinator with the Illinois Network for Pretrial Justice.

Dart's spokesperson disputed the characterization, saying inspectors found the jail in compliance with the vast majority of state standards each year.

The jail was previously subject to independent monitoring under federal consent decrees, but those ended in 2017. Jails in New York, Los Angeles, Denver, and Philadelphia currently operate under some form of outside oversight beyond regulatory inspections.

In September, Cook County Commissioner Tara Stamps and four co-sponsors introduced a resolution calling for an "independent review" of the jail focused on detainee health, safety, and conditions of confinement. Stamps pulled the measure from a committee vote after colleagues warned it could create legal liability. An analysis by the state's attorney's office said the resolution would be "harmful" to the county's legal position in pending and future litigation and could not unilaterally order Dart to open the jail to a monitor, citing state law giving sheriffs final policymaking authority over county jails.

Stamps told the Illinois Answers Project she would revise and reintroduce the resolution this month, but had not done so as of publication. She did not respond to requests for comment.

Last week, a group of interfaith clergy published an op-ed in the Chicago Sun-Times urging commissioners to advance Stamps' resolution. "The public deserves a clear explanation of how delaying an independent review serves the interests of those in custody and the broader community," they wrote.

Separately, Cook County Inspector General Tirrell J. Paxton issued six recommendations to the sheriff's office in September following a review of more than 100 complaints. Paxton found that the office "generally takes appropriate action" but identified "recurring deficiencies in investigative consistency, documentation, and case management." Dart's general counsel, Nicholas Scouffas, rejected all the recommendations, saying Paxton lacked the authority and information to make them. The county board is weighing whether to hold a hearing on Paxton's oversight role.

Jennifer Vollen-Katz, executive director of the John Howard Association of Illinois, a prison watchdog group that monitored the jail from 1988 to 2011, said independent oversight would ultimately reduce the county's exposure to lawsuits.

"Sometimes just knowing you're being watched prevents people from behaving badly," Vollen-Katz said.

Since Ulmer's death, at least 28 additional detainees have died at the jail, records show. Jail officials have enacted a dozen policy changes following Ulmer's death, including installing cameras to eliminate blind spots in the jail's hospital and instructing staff to provide water to detainees in the bullpen.

More from The Chicago Focal