Local
Court Halts Army's Plan to Detonate 5 Tons of Toxic Lead Azide at Iowa Ammunition Plant
A one-sentence court order has indefinitely suspended the Army's plan to blow up 68 barrels of shock-sensitive lead azide near the Illinois border, giving environmental groups and worried residents a reprieve while a judge weighs whether the blast can proceed.
A federal court has indefinitely blocked the U.S. Army's plan to detonate five tons of a toxic, shock-sensitive explosive at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant near Middletown, Iowa, handing a victory to environmental groups and residents who feared a cloud of lead dust could drift across state lines into Illinois.
The one-sentence administrative stay, issued late Thursday, puts the emergency permit granted by the Environmental Protection Agency on hold until a judge rules on a broader request to stop the blast. The order came in a lawsuit filed by the Iowa Environmental Council and the Sierra Club.
"An administrative stay of the emergency permit issued by the Environmental Protection Agency is granted until the emergency motion for stay is ruled upon by this court," the order states.
The detonation had originally been scheduled for Friday, then pushed to Monday to allow the Army more time to explain the plan to the public. It could still proceed Monday if the court rules before the scheduled time, but for now the 68 barrels of lead azide remain in storage.
The material, used in bomb-making and other explosive devices, has sat at the site for nearly two decades. Recent investigations found that the lead azide, which is stored in water-filled barrels, has recrystallized and become volatile, raising the risk of an accidental explosion. The Army argues the stockpile is degrading and increasingly dangerous, and that moving it would itself risk a blast. Officials supporting the detonation say cold weather could make the material even more unstable, making time of the essence before winter.
The plan drew sharp criticism from residents and elected leaders in Iowa and neighboring states, who warned that toxic lead dust could be carried by wind and settle on homes, soil and farmland. Illinois lawmakers sent a forceful letter to the Army and EPA on Thursday urging a delay.
"We call on you to consider delaying this detonation until there is an opportunity to explore safer alternatives," the lawmakers wrote. "Lead dust is particularly harmful to children and pregnant women. It can contaminate soil and critical farmland indefinitely."
Illinois Public Health Director Dr. Sameer Vohra issued guidance for residents who might be affected, saying they could reduce risk by staying indoors and keeping windows closed for 24 to 48 hours, washing hands before eating and drinking, and cleaning outdoor surfaces with soap and water.
"We will continue to work with the Illinois EPA and local health departments to protect the safety of Illinois from the health risks associated from toxic lead," Vohra said.
University of Iowa public health professor Patrick O'Shaughnessy called the planned detonation of such a hazardous material unprecedented, pointing in particular to the vulnerability of young children.
"Maybe the most concerning thing is 2-year-olds that just have this habit of right of touching everything and then everything goes right into their mouth," he said.
Sen. Chuck Grassley said the delay from Friday to Monday was meant to give the Army time to "further educate the public" and respond to questions from Iowans.
"The Army is responding to the questions and concerns I've shared from Iowans. I've emphasized the need for increased communication," Grassley said Thursday.
As a precaution, the Army plans to saturate the ground with water and use misters before and during any detonation to keep some of the material from becoming airborne. The lead azide is currently stored inside water-filled barrels within concrete buildings covered with earth.
The court's intervention means the disposal effort, which has been months in the making, is now on hold until a judge decides whether the blast can go forward at all.