Friday, November 20, 2026·Focal News

The Chicago Focal

Chicago's independent voice

Local

South Deering Residents Win Court Order Against Foul-Smelling Plant as Federal Environmental Protections Dwindle

A Cook County judge ordered Pullman Innovations to halt odor-emitting operations until January, handing South Deering residents a rare victory in their years-long fight against industrial pollution. The ruling comes as federal environmental justice tools and enforcement are being dismantled, leaving communities like theirs to rely on state and local action.

South Deering Residents Win Court Order Against Foul-Smelling Plant as Federal Environmental Protections Dwindle

Residents of Chicago's South Deering neighborhood have secured a temporary court order forcing a local plant to stop emitting foul odors, marking a rare win in a long battle against industrial pollution that has been complicated by federal deregulation and the removal of key environmental justice tools.

Cook County Circuit Judge Thomas Donnelly ordered Pullman Innovations on Oct. 14 to halt any operations that release odors into surrounding neighborhoods. The facility, which turns vegetable oil into animal feed, must remain shut down until Jan. 14 or until it comes into legal compliance, according to court filings. The order followed a lawsuit filed over the summer by the city of Chicago and Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul alleging "noisome organic odors."

The plant has been a source of misery for years, according to residents who have compared the smell to "dead bodies," "fresh vomit" and "rotting meat" in frequent calls to 311. DePaul University's Center for Journalism Integrity and Excellence found 194 air and odor complaints filed with the city dating back to 2022, obtained through Freedom of Information Act requests.

Oscar Ortega, a South Deering resident who filed a class-action lawsuit against Pullman Innovations in 2023, said he has taped up his windows to keep the smell out. "The only way I can compare it to is being incarcerated," Ortega said. "You can't come out."

Susan Sadlowski Garza, who represented the 10th Ward as alderperson from 2015 to 2023, said her office was inundated with complaints. "Every day we would get calls. Every day," she said. "On Monday, when we would come back to the office, our machine was full of 'it smells, it stinks.'"

Peggy Salazar, another South Deering resident, said the odors force families to keep windows closed even on pleasant summer nights, driving up air conditioning costs. "Technically, on a nice, cool summer night, we should be able to open our windows. … But we don't if we get those smells," she said. "We keep them closed, so that means now we turn on the air conditioning, which means it costs us money."

Salazar has organized protests alongside her friend Jim Kinney, a fellow South Deering native who believes the plant should be relocated away from residential areas. "Move this company out of here and set up somewhere else," Kinney said. "Not near any communities." He added: "We really are a dumping ground in this ward. It's bad for the future of the kids that are going to be growing up here."

The local fight has unfolded against a backdrop of retreat by federal environmental regulators. Since President Donald Trump began his second term in 2025, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, under Administrator Lee Zeldin, has dismantled its Office of Environmental Justice, canceled nearly $60 million in contracts related to environmental justice and diversity programs, and removed the Environmental Justice Screening and Mapping Tool, known as EJScreen, from its website.

Matthew Tejada, the EPA's former deputy assistant administrator for environmental justice, said the removal of EJScreen was a deliberate attack on vulnerable communities. "The fact that they would take a tool down like EJScreen, to me, is an act of oppression to continue to hold down, to pollute, to really victimize communities of color, indigenous communities and low income white communities across the United States," said Tejada, now senior vice president of environmental health at the Natural Resources Defense Council.

The EPA press office defended its actions in a statement, saying the Biden administration's "obsession with radical climate policies and furthering divisive and destructive DEI policies fly in the face of those commitments and were, frankly, un-American."

The federal pullback has also affected a landmark civil rights agreement. In 2023, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development entered a voluntary compliance agreement with Chicago after finding the city violated the Civil Rights Act by proposing to move a metal recycling facility from the predominantly white Lincoln Park neighborhood to the predominantly Black and Hispanic Southeast Side. The agreement included provisions for increased transparency and land-use reform. According to Mayor Brandon Johnson's office, the Trump administration withdrew from the agreement in August 2025, nearly a year before it was set to expire.

In response, Chicago has pressed forward with its own initiatives. In April, Johnson introduced the Hazel Johnson Cumulative Impact Ordinance, which created an Environmental Justice Advisory Board and established an Environmental Justice Project Manager position in the Chicago Department of Environment. "Even when the federal government does not fulfill its commitments, the City will continue driving forward environmental justice through our programs and initiatives," said Kathleen O'Shea, director of public affairs for the department.

Illinois has also stepped up. On Aug. 7, Gov. J.B. Pritzker signed three bills aimed at insulating the state from the federal anti-environment agenda, including one creating an Office of Environmental Justice within the Illinois EPA. The office is implementing an enforcement strategy focused on protecting all residents from pollution and increasing inspections of potential violations.

"I'm encouraged that we have a partner agency in the IEPA that's putting emphasis on environmental justice," Raoul said. He added that it is "critically important" to highlight communities that have disproportionately suffered from pollutants. "And to the extent that we have had tools to lift that up and then we're taking those away, I don't think that's in the interest of just public interest at large and protecting communities at large."

An Illinois EPA inspection on Aug. 26, three weeks after the city and state filed their lawsuit, found the odor present in areas surrounding the facility. The inspector described the smell as "vile, pungent and extremely unpleasant" depending on wind direction, and the report alleged Pullman Innovations "caused or allowed the discharge of odorous emission," violating multiple state laws.

Pullman Innovations did not respond to a request for comment. In its legal defense, the company has argued that the smell cannot be attributed solely to its factory because other industrial sites operate nearby.

Despite the temporary restraining order, Pullman Innovations appeared to still be operating nearly a month after the order was put in place, according to reporting from DePaul's journalism center. The attorney general's office said it continues to be in touch with the Illinois EPA and is "committed to requiring Pullman to comply with the requirements of the TRO," but did not directly state whether the plant remains active.

Ortega said he remains skeptical about enforcement until the judge decides on a permanent injunction. "We still need to see if that's going to happen," he said. He noted that similar odors would not be tolerated in the suburbs or "nicer neighborhoods" across Chicago. "But why does it make it okay for South Chicago or South Deering to have that," he asked, "and not being able to do anything about it?"

The court will hear oral arguments on the plant's motion to dismiss on Dec. 16. Meanwhile, residents like Salazar say the fight is about more than just the smell. "It's definitely impacting your property values. It's definitely impacting what type of investment comes into your community," she said. "It overshadows everything."

More from The Chicago Focal