Local
Evanston Preservation Commission Votes to Pursue Landmark Status for Modernist Chase Bank, Blocking Demolition
Evanston's Preservation Commission unanimously advanced landmark designation for a 47-year-old David Haid-designed Chase bank branch, halting JPMorgan Chase's demolition plans and setting up a City Council vote. The decision pits the bank's claim of $3 million in repairs against preservationists who call the building a rare example of Second Chicago School architecture.
Evanston's Preservation Commission voted 9-0 on Wednesday evening to pursue landmark status for a one-story brick-and-glass Chase bank branch at 1900 Central St., blocking JPMorgan Chase's plans to demolish the 47-year-old building and replace it with a new branch.
The commission found that the structure, designed by architect David Haid, meets two key criteria for designation: it is a unique architectural type and the work of a significant architect. The vote immediately protects the building's exterior from demolition and unsympathetic alterations until a final landmark decision is made.
The decision requires Evanston's preservation staff to prepare a report detailing the building's architectural significance and a draft resolution in favor of landmarking. Both documents will return to the commission for a vote in the next few months. If approved, they would be sent to the Evanston City Council for a final vote on permanent landmark status.
Haid, who died in 1993 at age 64, studied under Ludwig Mies van der Rohe at the Illinois Institute of Technology and worked in the famed architect's Chicago office before establishing his own practice. The Evanston bank, built in 1979 for FirstBank and later acquired by JPMorgan Chase, is described in a report from the city's Office of Historic Preservation as "one of the purest, most refined expressions of the Second Chicago School" during the Late Modernism era.
"I think that the work of Mies' disciples like David Haid is important," said commission member Stuart Cohen, a prominent architect who co-founded the group known as the Chicago Seven in the 1970s. "I would make the argument that the significance of Mies' architecture and buildings like this done by people that he trained is unique."
Cohen added: "No one's building structures like this anymore. There aren't really that many of them around, and none of them are as good as this."
JPMorgan Chase opposed the designation. Kenneth Colliander, a vice president and architect for the bank, told the commission that the branch's exposed steel structure is weathered and rusted and requires at least $3 million in repairs. Preservation consultant George Kisiel of Okrent Kisiel Associates argued that neither the building nor Haid's body of work is distinguished enough to merit landmarking, saying the structure "fails to be distinguished by innovation, rarity, uniqueness, or overall quality of design, detail and materials." Kisiel also said Haid's work consists of "lesser commissions that are not recognized by local or national chapters of the American Institute of Architects."
The commission rejected those arguments. Evanston resident James McKee, who researched the building's history and recommended it for designation, urged the bank to see the vote as an opportunity.
"I hope Chase won't view this as a defeat but rather as an opportunity," McKee said. "Chase is the custodian of an important piece of Evanston's architectural history, and I hope they'll embrace that role by restoring and improving the building while adapting the interior to meet their current needs."
Philip Castillo, managing director at the architecture firm Jahn and a supporter of the designation, described the building's structural elegance to the commission. "If one strips away the brick and glass, there is a simple steel roof plane supported by four elegant columns," Castillo said. "The result is a simple, column-free interior space."
Haid's other works include the Walter H. Dyett High School for the Arts in Chicago, designed with Black architect Kenneth Childers; his own Evanston residence; and the Ben Rose House auto pavilion, which appeared in the film "Ferris Bueller's Day Off." Kisiel dismissed the latter as "a garage."
The commission's vote came after nearly two hours of testimony. The building's fate now rests with the preservation staff's report and, ultimately, the City Council. JPMorgan Chase, which is spending $800 million to renovate Chase Tower in Chicago and reportedly $6 billion on a new headquarters in New York, has not indicated whether it will appeal the decision or adapt its plans.
McKee said the bank could turn the building into "a source of community pride and goodwill and maybe even a way to attract some new customers through the door."