Local
Chicago's Booting Crisis: South and West Side Drivers Bear the Brunt of Debt Trap
A new analysis of over 283,000 booted vehicles reveals that drivers in Black and working-class neighborhoods on Chicago's South and West Sides are booted at twice the citywide rate, with critics calling the program a regressive debt trap and city officials defending it as necessary enforcement.
Chicago's vehicle booting program is hitting drivers in Black and working-class neighborhoods on the South and West Sides far harder than the rest of the city, according to a new analysis of more than 283,000 vehicles booted between January 2020 and December 2025.
The analysis, conducted by WBEZ and the Chicago Sun-Times, found that drivers in Englewood, Oakland, West Garfield Park, and parts of Austin, East Garfield Park, Humboldt Park, and Woodlawn were booted at rates twice the citywide average. These same areas have among the highest numbers of drivers on the city's boot list, which currently includes more than 1.1 million boot-eligible drivers.
Red-light and speed camera tickets were the leading violations that landed drivers on the boot list every year. About one in four booted drivers were booted more than once. The median amount owed by booted drivers was roughly $650, though one driver owed more than $106,000. During the six-year period, about 43,000 vehicles were booted and towed, and as of January 9, more than 12,000 had not been returned to their owners.
Critics say the combination of automated enforcement, high ticket prices, and mounting fees for delinquent tickets creates a debt trap that can quickly overwhelm low-income drivers. Once booted, drivers have 24 hours to pay their debt or make a deposit on a payment plan, plus a $100 boot removal fee. If they fail to respond, the city tows and impounds the vehicle, adding a $150 tow fee for most cars and a $50 daily storage fee. After 45 days, the city can auction or dispose of the vehicle.
"These debts can spiral out of control really quickly and become quite invasive in a person's life," said Kasey Henricks, an assistant professor in the University of Illinois Chicago's Department of Criminology, Law and Justice. "Literally taking people's cars away is taking away their mobility in a place where their livelihood is dependent upon that. It completely devastates people's lives if you have outstanding ticket debt in Chicago."
Henricks noted that the consequences of late penalties, collection fees, and booting are concentrated in majority Black neighborhoods and, to a lesser extent, majority Latinx communities.
Davorian Ware knows the nightmare firsthand. In August 2021, he parked his 2010 Mitsubishi sedan at a city overnight airport lot before flying to Las Vegas. When he returned three days later, his car was booted. It was the second time he'd been booted. Over a year and a half, he had amassed 21 tickets and owed $2,811.57. He had been on payment plans three times and defaulted each time, the last time after losing his job during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Ware said he didn't realize he had so many tickets or that he was violating driving compliance laws by not having a front license plate. "I didn't know at all, and also there was nothing I could mount" the plate on, he said. "There weren't any holes on the front of my bumper."
Under city policy, drivers who default three times on payment plans cannot reinstate a new one unless they are booted again, pay a reinstatement fee, and pay up to 22% of the delinquent balance. Ware said he was told he had to pay in full, which he couldn't afford. He left the car, and the city towed it to a pound. Weeks later, it was sold at auction for $262.08.
Nearly a year and a half after he last saw his Mitsubishi, Ware noticed his paycheck was short by about $310. The city had garnished his wages through the Illinois state comptroller's Local Debt Recovery Program. His checks were garnished for four months.
"That's double punishment," Ware said. "If y'all took my car, at least wipe away the slate, or give me my car back."
City Comptroller Michael Belsky acknowledged that the situation is difficult. "I wouldn't be happy about it," he said, adding that the city tries to avoid such outcomes. "We don't want people to be making a choice between paying their tickets and childcare and healthcare and food." But he said those who violate the law are expected to pay something. Belsky noted that 75% of drivers who get a ticket pay up, and problems arise when people don't pay and fines escalate.
Belsky defended the program's fairness, saying the technology used to scan license plates is "not biased" and that enforcement zones are data-driven and equitable. He pointed to the city's Clear Path Relief program, which allows drivers with incomes at or below 300% of the federal poverty level to pay off original violation amounts for tickets within three years and have other debt forgiven, provided they stay on a payment plan for a year.
Mayor Brandon Johnson's office said in a statement that the administration "recognizes and understands the burden mounting debt and late penalties places on working families." The statement pointed to a 2025 debt amnesty effort and a new Vehicle Debt Amnesty Program in the mayor's budget that would allow residents to resolve debt by paying only the original fine while waiving late penalties and fees.
But the city also added 50 new speed cameras in 2025, leading to a surge in tickets. In June 2025 alone, when 22 new cameras came online, the city issued 240,000 speed-camera tickets, the highest monthly total in nearly three years. And the City Council Office of Financial Analysis has circulated a 2027 revenue proposal that includes options to raise towing and storage fees.
Mark Wallace, executive director of Citizens to Abolish Red Light Cameras, called Chicago's ticketing program "probably one of the most regressive ticketing programs in the country." His group sued the city for failing to comply with its own rules on red-light camera tickets, resulting in a $38.75 million settlement in 2017.
"I just think that the city is not very creative in trying to find ways to expand the tax base but find the easiest way to collect revenue, and those easiest ways tend to prey on lower-income Black and brown communities," Wallace said. He called the booting program "barbaric and unjust" and said it should be a last resort.
Penney McDonald, a mother of three who moved to the South Side in 2013, said she was booted at least three times after accumulating 44 tickets between May 2014 and June 2026, with fines totaling nearly $6,000. She said she established at least 15 payment plans but defaulted on more than 11 of them. At one point, her car was impounded while she was pregnant, forcing her to do everything on foot.
"We had to use the shopping carts to push our groceries back home," McDonald said. "It was just ghetto and heart-wrenching at the same time. You don't want to rack up a lot of tickets in Chicago. As a single parent, that is one of the worst situations you can put yourself in."
"People don't understand that when you lose your vehicle, you have lost your whole lifeline," she said. "It's so very hard to get back to where you once were."