Friday, November 20, 2026·Focal News

The Chicago Focal

Chicago's independent voice

Local

Avondale Trading Card Shop Owner Says Thief Swiped $6,500 in Pokémon Cards

A thief walked into Oldskool TCG in Avondale and slipped four high-end Pokémon cards worth about $6,500 into his jacket while the owner helped another customer, according to surveillance video. Owner Nick Bruni, who opened the shop a few months ago, has filed a police report and is asking the public for help identifying the suspect.

Avondale Trading Card Shop Owner Says Thief Swiped $6,500 in Pokémon Cards

A new Avondale trading card shop is reeling after its owner says a customer pocketed four high-end Pokémon cards worth roughly $6,500 in a theft captured on surveillance video.

Nick Bruni, who opened Oldskool TCG a few months ago, said the theft happened Tuesday while he was helping another customer. A box of newly arrived inventory was sitting next to the register, and video shows a man fumbling through it before slipping something into his jacket.

"Just had this box of inventory sitting right here. Obviously, huge error on my part," Bruni said.

One of the stolen cards alone was worth more than $4,000, Bruni said. The four cards together are valued at about $6,500.

Bruni, a longtime Pokémon collector, said he normally keeps valuable cards behind glass. "Because of the value of the cards, I definitely like to keep everything behind glass," he said.

The theft stung beyond the dollar figure. Bruni said the same person had earlier sold him other cards, meaning he both paid the man for cards and then was robbed by him.

"The fact that I worked so hard to build this business, and I treat everyone with the utmost respect; I'm super trusting of everyone who comes into the shop, and to have that trust violated by someone coming in and stealing what's mine, that's what really gets to me," he said.

Bruni filed a police report and shared his surveillance footage in hopes of identifying the thief. Police classified the incident as simple retail theft.

He said such thefts are becoming more common for small card shops, and he hopes speaking out will help other owners tighten their own procedures.

In the Pokémon fan world, Bruni said, the accused thief has earned a comparison to Jessie and James, the bumbling villain duo from the franchise.

"They're the villains of the Pokémon universe," he said.

Anyone with information about the theft is asked to contact Chicago police.

More from The Chicago Focal