Local
Charlotte Seeks Dismissal of Zarutska Family Lawsuit, Citing Immunity
The city of Charlotte has asked a judge to throw out a lawsuit filed by the family of Iryna Zarutska, arguing governmental immunity, failure to state a claim, and the public duty doctrine. The city contends that systemwide crime statistics do not make a violent attack on a transit passenger reasonably foreseeable.
The city of Charlotte has filed a motion asking a judge to dismiss a lawsuit brought by the family of Iryna Zarutska, whose death on a light rail train prompted widespread calls for safety reforms. In the filing, city attorneys assert three grounds for dismissal: governmental immunity, failure to state a claim, and the public duty doctrine.
The motion argues that the familyâs allegations about crime across the transit system and at individual stations do not establish that a violent assault on a passenger under the circumstances described was reasonably foreseeable. âThe City contends that the allegations concerning systemwide crime and incidents at transit terminals do not establish that a violent attack on a passenger under the circumstances alleged was reasonably foreseeable,â the motion states.
The lawsuit, filed by an attorney for Zarutskaâs family, named both the city and a security company as defendants. It sought to hold them accountable for the conditions that led to her death. The cityâs response, filed Monday, does not address the specific security failures alleged but instead challenges the legal basis of the claims.
A judge will review the filing and decide at a later date whether the case can proceed. The outcome could have broader implications for how local governments in North Carolina handle claims involving transit safety and the foreseeability of violent crime.
Zarutskaâs death has already spurred legislative action. A measure known as Irynaâs Law, which aims to strengthen penalties and prevention efforts related to attacks on public transit, has been highlighted by local officials. The case has also intensified scrutiny of security practices on Charlotteâs light rail system, where riders and advocates have long raised concerns about safety.
The cityâs motion is the latest development in a legal battle that has drawn attention from residents across the Charlotte area. For the Zarutska family, the dismissal request represents a significant hurdle in their pursuit of accountability. For city officials, it is a defense of municipal legal protections that could shape how similar cases are handled in the future.
No hearing date has been set. The judgeâs eventual ruling will determine whether the lawsuit moves forward or is dismissed on the grounds asserted by the city.