Local
Charlotte Approves $1.7M Settlement in 2020 Protest Lawsuit
The city of Charlotte has agreed to pay $1.7 million to 67 claimants who alleged they were tear-gassed, shot with pepper balls, and trapped by police during a June 2020 protest over George Floyd's death. The settlement, which the city says is not an admission of wrongdoing, comes five years after the class action was filed and follows policy changes at CMPD.
CHARLOTTE, N.C. â The city of Charlotte has approved a $1.7 million settlement in a class action lawsuit stemming from a June 2020 protest, resolving a case that has lingered for five years and drawn attention to police tactics during a national reckoning over racial justice.
The settlement, announced by the city, will distribute $25,746 to each of the 67 claimants who alleged they were tear-gassed, hit with pepper balls, and trapped by Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Department officers during a demonstration in Uptown Charlotte on June 2, 2020.
The protest was one of many held across the country that summer following the death of George Floyd at the hands of Minneapolis police. According to the lawsuit, what began as a peaceful gathering turned into a chaotic scene when CMPD officers used a tactic known as âkettlingâ â a maneuver in which officers surround protesters from the front and back, blocking exit routes â before deploying chemical munitions and projectiles.
Body camera footage later released appeared to show bike unit leaders discussing a plan to purposefully tear gas protesters on both sides of Fourth Street. The lawsuit alleged that officers then assaulted the crowd with rubber bullets, tear gas, stinger grenades, and pepper balls fired from a parking deck adjacent to the block.
âThere was a premeditated assault on people who were expressing their First Amendment rights,â said Tim Emry, one of the attorneys representing the protesters.
His colleague Alex Heroy said the legal team reviewed hundreds of hours of video. âThey were out expressing their views. Thatâs what America is about,â Heroy said. âIn our view, they were attacked for that.â
Katie Rothweiler, one of the claimants, described the night as disorienting and terrifying. âWe were all choking and could not breathe,â she said. âEveryone ended up kind of dropping to their knees and putting their hands up, begging to not be shot.â
Rothweiler said the trauma has persisted. âI still have reactions to loud noises, large crowds. A lot of things are triggering for me,â she said. âIâve done a lot of therapy to work through it, but it still affects me. I am very uncomfortable around police officers. I will do whatever I can to walk on the other side of the street or stay away from them if at all possible.â
In a statement, the city said the settlement âavoids the significant expense and uncertainty of prolonged trial proceedingsâ but âdoes not constitute an admission of liability or wrongdoing by the City or the Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Department.â The statement added that the city âremains focused on continuing its work with residents and community leaders to strengthen trust and accountability across Charlotte.â
CMPD referred a request for comment to the cityâs statement.
Lauren Newton, another attorney for the plaintiffs, said the cityâs decision to settle speaks for itself. âWhat weâve seen through what the mayor said, and what other elected officials said closer in time to when this happened, is that we all know what happened,â Newton said. âOur city spoke out, and ultimately the city council approving the settlement speaks volumes.â
Beyond the payout, the case has already led to changes in how CMPD handles protests. The department no longer uses chemical munitions on peaceful protesters, and officers are prohibited from blocking designated exit routes.
Darlene Harris, an attorney with Power in Protection Law Firm, said such reforms are what communities want. âI think that what the community wants to see, and what people want to see is to see the police department being proactive and taking into account, before a tragedy happens, how to navigate change,â Harris said.
For Rothweiler, the money was never the point. âThe systemic changes are the reason that we were protesting in the first place,â she said. âThatâs why we were out there. Thatâs why we have continued to fight for this.â
The settlement closes a chapter on one of Charlotteâs most contentious episodes of 2020, but the debate over policing and protest tactics continues nationally. For the 67 claimants, the resolution offers compensation and, they say, a measure of acknowledgment.