Politics
ACLU, Legal Voice, Teachers Union Sue to Block Washington's Trans Sports Ban
A coalition of civil rights and education groups filed an emergency lawsuit just days after Washington voters approved Initiative 638, arguing the measure violates the state constitution's equal rights and privacy protections. The ban, set to take effect December 3, would require all girl student-athletes to verify their biological sex and end nearly two decades of trans-inclusive school sports.
Washington's newly passed Initiative 638, which bans transgender girls from playing on youth sports teams at public schools and requires all girl student-athletes to prove their biological sex, is now facing an emergency legal challenge. Three days after the initiative results were certified, the ACLU of Washington, gender equality advocacy group Legal Voice, and the statewide teachers union Washington Education Association filed a lawsuit seeking to prevent the measure from taking effect on December 3.
The complaint argues that I-638, which passed with 56 percent of the vote, violates multiple provisions of the state constitution. Because the measure applies only to girls' sports and transgender athletes, advocates contend it would violate Washington's Equal Rights Amendment. The sex verification requirement, they say, would also violate student privacy, which is protected under the state constitution.
"This new requirement is in direct conflict with the state's paramount duty to educate our children without discrimination," said Janie White, president of the Washington Education Association, which represents 90,000 educators, in a news release. "Washington educators are committed to fair and welcoming schools where all students can thrive."
If allowed to go into effect, I-638 would abruptly end Washington's nearly 20-year history of trans-inclusive school sports. The measure's enforcement mechanism remains vague. According to the initiative's original language, the sex verification requirement would come from "leveraging the existing physical examination process to verify biological sex." But the standard sports physical form used statewide under the Washington Interscholastic Activities Association (WIAA) does not address biological sex at allâit only notes physical attributes and conditions that might make playing sports unsafe. The initiative does not explain how the sports physical process would be altered or how it would apply to students who have already obtained a physical for the school year.
"This is going to be very chaotic for school districts to implement, because we have no clue how they're going to do that," said Adrien Leavitt of the ACLU.
Legal Voice policy director Alizeh Bhojani raised further concerns about the burden the verification requirement would place on families. "Will that require new medical appointments?" she said. "If it's not medically necessary, will that be covered by insurance? If a family opts for hormone or genetic testing, that's going to be even more costly and inconvenient and a delay."
Bhojani also framed the measure as part of a larger attack on transgender people. "This is definitely part of a broader pattern to push trans people out of public life," she said, citing bathroom bills and ongoing conservative efforts to restrict access to gender-affirming care.
Opposition to the measure has grown since its passage. Last week, the Seattle Public Schools board of directors voted to support the district legally challenging the law. Mayor Katie Wilson cosigned the move on social media, writing, "I support the Board's decision and its commitment to creating inclusive learning environments where every student has the opportunity to reach their full potential."
On Friday, Attorney General Nick Brown announced that to avoid a conflict of interest, he was bringing in an outside law firmâPacifica Law Groupâto defend the measure in court. The attorney general's office has previously advocated on behalf of transgender Washingtonians, and Brown said, "We will not and cannot abandon that work."
Defenders of the initiative have argued that transgender athletes have an unfair advantage in girls' sports, but advocates say that claim is not supported by science. A literature review published in Frontiers in Sport and Active Living found little data to back it up. "There are no legitimate cases of this occurring," wrote author DJ Oberlin. "An individual's sex does not determine their success or failure at any athletic event despite the high level of competition."
Aidan Key, who advocated for Washington's trans-inclusive school sports policy when it was first introduced in 2007, said educators and rule-making organizations have noted "no distinguishable difference" in athletic performance between trans and cis student athletes. "So this idea that trans girls are going to be dominating girls' sports is not happening," he said.
On Tuesday, the Seattle Times reported that the WIAA would update its policies to align with I-638 by the December 3 implementation date, requiring girls in winter sports to confirm their biological sex by then. Bhojani said she hopes an injunction blocking the measure will be granted before that deadline.