Wednesday, November 18, 2026·Focal News

The Seattle Focal

Seattle's independent voice

Politics

Washington Tribes Mobilize Against Senate Permitting Bill Ahead of Key Vote

Tribal nations in Washington and across the U.S. are urging senators to reject or amend the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, warning that its sweeping changes to environmental and historic preservation laws threaten cultural resources, water quality, and tribal sovereignty.

Washington Tribes Mobilize Against Senate Permitting Bill Ahead of Key Vote

WASHINGTON, D.C. — Tribal nations in Washington state and across the country have become leading opponents of a sweeping Senate bill that would accelerate federal permitting for energy and infrastructure projects, arguing that the legislation would weaken environmental protections and erode tribal sovereignty.

The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, a 494-page measure expected to face a Senate vote this week, would overhaul the National Environmental Policy Act, the Clean Water Act, the Endangered Species Act, and the National Historic Preservation Act. Supporters say the changes would cut delays for power plants, gas pipelines, transmission lines, and other projects as electricity demand surges from data centers powering artificial intelligence, and would help address Americans' affordability concerns following a midterm election defined by the issue.

But tribal leaders say the bill's provisions would shrink the timelines for challenging projects and reduce the scope of environmental reviews, making it harder for tribes to participate and seek legal recourse.

"We do need to do some work on permit reform, commonsense permit reform," Leonard Forsman, chairman of the Suquamish Tribe and president of the Affiliated Tribes of Northwest Indians, said in an interview. "But this isn't it: Just to give a free pass to the energy industry."

"This is a real disaster for cultural resource management, and for water quality and salmon, too," he added.

The Affiliated Tribes of Northwest Indians, which represents 57 tribal governments from Washington and nearby states, endorsed an opposition statement on Nov. 8 alongside other major Indigenous groups. Multiple Washington tribes have also individually raised objections.

Melissa A. Gilman, chair of the Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe, wrote in a Nov. 8 letter to members of Congress that proposed changes to key provisions of the historic preservation act are especially concerning. "Our ancestral places are not renewable resources. Once destroyed, they cannot be replaced," she wrote. "The decisions Congress makes today will determine whether future generations inherit the cultural landscapes, history and connections to place that our ancestors entrusted to our care."

An analysis by the Native American Rights Fund, a legal nonprofit that assists tribal nations, found that the bill would substantially impair provisions requiring federal agencies to consult with tribes.

The Lummi Nation cited the historic preservation act and the environmental policy act this year in suing federal agencies over alleged damage to ancestral burial grounds in Point Roberts. The lawsuit accuses the federal government of allowing a telecommunications company to dig trenches through the burial grounds without consulting the tribe.

Tribal leaders say infrastructure projects can succeed under the existing process and that permitting reforms can be made without gutting cultural protections — if tribal nations are involved.

"The Squaxin Island Tribe, like other tribes, relies on robust and meaningful consultation with federal agencies," Squaxin Island Chair Kris Peters said in an email this week, arguing that Congress should wholly remove the bill's proposed historic preservation act changes.

The Senate bill is the product of closed-door negotiations between lawmakers from both parties and the Trump administration. It has not received a committee hearing in the Republican-controlled chamber, a typical process that solicits wider input.

Republicans often lead the way on bills aimed at cutting red tape for business and industry, but the measure has garnered support from some Democrats who want to advance clean-energy projects they believe are needed to combat climate change, said Greg Werkheiser, a historic preservation attorney representing Lummi Nation in its Point Roberts lawsuit.

The legislation's Senate champions amended the bill this month in response to tribal concerns, paring back some changes and extending some deadline windows. They touted the revised bill as an effort that will lower energy costs for Americans while still honoring tribal treaty rights. Tribal leaders say the revisions are not adequate.

Washington's Democratic senators, Patty Murray and Maria Cantwell, have opposed efforts to move the legislation forward in recent weeks. Murray said she wants "America to build more, to build quicker" and bring prices down but shares concerns she has heard from Washington tribes.

Cantwell called the bill dangerous as written. "Generations would suffer because of it," she said at a news conference Tuesday. "We all need new sources of energy and power. But this bill as it's currently drafted is not the answer." She added, "I hope we can slow down, and if we can't, I hope the House stops it."

Washington Gov. Bob Ferguson and Attorney General Nick Brown have also cited tribal considerations in calling on Senate leaders to pause the legislation.

If the bill passes the Senate, it heads to the House, where its fate is unclear. Democrats appear divided: the Congressional Progressive Caucus, which includes Reps. Pramila Jayapal of Seattle and Emily Randall of Bremerton, has said it opposes the legislation as written, while the New Democrat Coalition, which includes several other Washington members, has signaled support.

Rep. Rick Larsen of Everett said Tuesday he was unsure where he would land, weighing concerns about tribal sovereignty alongside some labor unions' jobs-related support for the bill.

Major environmental groups have echoed the tribes' concerns, while some clean-energy advocates back the bill's clean-energy goals.

More from The Seattle Focal