Tuesday, November 17, 2026·Focal News

The Seattle Focal

Seattle's independent voice

Local

Fall City teen Andrew Humiston pleads not guilty to murdering five family members

Andrew Humiston, 17, pleaded not guilty Tuesday to five charges in the 2024 shooting deaths of his parents and three siblings in Fall City, Washington. A King County judge ruled last month that he will be tried as an adult.

Fall City teen Andrew Humiston pleads not guilty to murdering five family members

A 17-year-old Fall City youth pleaded not guilty Tuesday to five charges stemming from the October 2024 shooting deaths of his parents and three siblings, a case that has drawn attention to questions of juvenile justice and family isolation.

Andrew Humiston entered the plea in King County Superior Court. He was 15 at the time of his arrest. Tuesday's arraignment was the first time news organizations were permitted to identify him or show his face, following a judge's order.

Last month, King County Judge Veronica Galván ruled after a two-week decline hearing that Humiston would be tried as an adult. Both prosecutors and defense attorneys presented arguments before her decision. The distinction is significant: if convicted as an adult, Humiston could face a sentence that leaves open the possibility of release in less than a decade, whereas a juvenile conviction would carry different sentencing parameters.

Prosecutors allege Humiston killed his parents and three siblings and shot and wounded his 11-year-old sister. According to police, the girl was shot in the neck but survived by playing dead until he left the room, then fled to a neighbor's home for help.

Court evidence described the crime scene and the steps investigators say the suspect took, including unlocking a pistol from a safe and retrieving an extra magazine. Police reports also allege he attempted to stage the scene to cast blame on his 13-year-old brother, shooting the boy a second time to make the death appear a suicide.

During the decline hearing, family members testified that they believed the children had been abused and were often isolated from any group outside their church.

The case has resonated in Fall City, a small community in King County, and beyond, raising difficult questions about how the justice system handles young defendants accused of extreme violence and what warning signs may have been missed.

The earliest the case could go to trial is sometime next year.

More from The Seattle Focal