Saturday, November 21, 2026·Focal News

The San Francisco Focal

San Francisco's independent voice

Politics

Vallejo Mayor Andrea Sorce Violated Ethics Rules, Independent Report Finds

A 153-page independent investigation released by the city of Vallejo found that Mayor Andrea Sorce violated multiple ethics and conduct rules by improperly seeking the removal of a high-level city employee with ties to the police department. The report, which the City Council voted to release after rejecting a resolution to condemn the mayor's conduct, substantiated claims that Sorce interfered with the employee's duties and unjustifiably accused her of violating the Brown Act.

Vallejo Mayor Andrea Sorce Violated Ethics Rules, Independent Report Finds

VALLEJO — An independent investigation released by the city of Vallejo on Thursday found that Mayor Andrea Sorce violated multiple city ethics and conduct rules by seeking the removal of a high-level city employee with ties to the Vallejo Police Department.

The 153-page report, conducted by investigators Douglas Ropel and Karen Herz of the Sacramento law firm Littler Mendelson, was launched after a high-level city employee filed complaints against Sorce and another unnamed party between April and June 2025. The employee's name was redacted in the public document.

The employee accused the mayor of discrimination and of trying to remove her from her role. Investigators substantiated the claim that Sorce prevented the employee from acting as Chief of Police during the Chief's absence in July 2025. They also found that Sorce "unjustifiably accused" the employee of violating the Brown Act, California's open meetings law.

Documentary evidence and multiple witness statements included in the report also supported claims that the mayor influenced the employee's reassignment away from homelessness-related responsibilities and excluded her from meetings involving Mare Island development, a project she had worked on for many years.

According to the report, these actions violated city laws that prevent the mayor from attempting to "coerce or influence" city employees and from "publicly criticizing an individual employee," among other things.

The employee also accused Sorce of taking action against her based on the perception that the employee "may have been involved in the investigation that led to the termination of the Mayor's husband." While investigators could not prove that Sorce was retaliating on behalf of her husband, they noted that "multiple councilmember witnesses have similar suspicions regarding the Mayor's motives."

Sorce's husband, Slater Matzke, was fired from his role in the City Manager's office in 2020 and was later a plaintiff in a successful $1.85 million wrongful termination lawsuit claiming that he and others were fired for calling out bad actors around a development on Mare Island.

The Vallejo City Council voted to release the report after rejecting a resolution earlier this month to "condemn and disavow" the mayor's conduct. At a tense Nov. 10 meeting, Sorce called the resolution a "sham" and said she learned about the allegations when the city council agenda was published.

"It's all because I had the audacity to call out, what appears, to me, to be corrupt practices, particularly in the Vallejo Police Department and the Vallejo City Attorney's Office," Sorce said at the meeting.

A newcomer to politics, Sorce became mayor in 2025 after campaigning on a police reform agenda. Before becoming mayor, she worked with Vallejo families affected by police violence to start the local American Civil Liberties Union chapter and advocated for reforming the city's police department after years of scandal.

"It has to change," Sorce said in a 2025 interview. "Any objective observer looking at this situation knows that there's a problem."

Vallejo's police department has a troubled history of violence and misconduct. In 2012, the rate of fatal shootings by officers in Vallejo — a suburb with around 118,000 residents at the time — was about 38 times the national rate. The department came under fire in 2020 for revelations that some officers bent the tips of their star-shaped badges after shooting someone. In 2024, VPD signed a settlement with California agreeing to implement 45 police reform recommendations. Their latest update, released in July 2026, showed that they achieved "substantial compliance" on 17% of the recommendations, with the department citing "staffing and resource constraints" as affecting progress.

In July 2025, the ACLU of Northern California urged the City Council to investigate the City Attorney's Office's role in handling police officer misconduct, alleging that City Attorney Veronica Nebb and her staff destroyed hundreds of pieces of evidence from six police shootings and maintained a shadow system for VPD records. The ACLU's letter noted that Mayor Sorce called for similar investigations. However, this week, the city announced it would not investigate these allegations further, according to a press release from the ACLU.

The release of the report comes as Vallejo continues to grapple with questions about accountability and transparency in city government. The findings against Sorce, who ran as a reformer, raise questions about the mayor's conduct and the city's handling of internal complaints.

More from The San Francisco Focal