Politics
Lurie, Mahmood Revive BUILD Act to Cut Transfer Taxes on $10M+ Property Sales
Mayor Daniel Lurie and Supervisor Bilal Mahmood are bringing back a scaled-back plan to reduce San Francisco's real estate transfer taxes on high-value property sales, aiming to spur housing construction while critics question the use of Prop. J revenue to offset the cuts.
Mayor Daniel Lurie and Supervisor Bilal Mahmood are resurrecting legislation to lower San Francisco's real estate transfer taxes on property sales of $10 million or more, a proposal they shelved in June over budget concerns.
The revised BUILD Act would cut the tax rate on sales between $10 million and $25 million from 5.5% to 3.5%, and on sales of $25 million or more from 6% to 4%. Those reductions are smaller than those in the original version introduced in February.
The measure would also exempt the first sale of newly constructed buildings with three or more housing units, along with certain early-stage sales of large development projects such as Treasure Island, Pier 70, and the Shipyard. Sales of single-family homes would remain subject to the current higher rates.
Lurie and Mahmood argue the changes would help stalled housing projects move forward by making it easier for developers to secure financing. The city has roughly 78,000 approved housing units in its pipeline, but only about 6,000 have been built over the past four years, according to the mayor's office. City estimates suggest the tax changes would save developers about $60,000 per unit.
The proposal was paused in June after criticism that it extended tax breaks to high-value property sales not tied to new housing. At the time, Mahmood said he would not proceed without a way to replace the lost revenue.
The two officials are now pointing to Proposition J, which voters approved in November with 80% support. The measure closes a loophole that exempted properties transferred through foreclosure or in lieu of foreclosure from the transfer tax. The Controller's Office estimates it could generate $100 million to $150 million over five years, roughly matching the projected cost of the tax cuts, though the controller warned that revenue could decline significantly over time.
Affordable housing advocates have questioned using that money to offset the tax reductions. Sunny Angulo, policy and strategy director for TODCO, called the proposal "more billionaire tax breaks," while Quintin Mecke, executive director of the Council of Community Housing Organizations, said Prop. J revenue should go toward building homes for working families.
The revived effort follows voters' rejection of Proposition I, which would have preserved the higher transfer tax rates and dedicated the revenue to affordable housing. Lurie campaigned against the measure, which lost 52% to 48%.
Separately, voters approved Proposition C, introduced by Supervisor Myrna Melgar, to expand the city's Affordable Housing Trust Fund to as much as $125 million annually and extend it through 2058. The fund supports affordable housing construction, rehabilitation, and homeownership programs. In July, however, the Board of Supervisors voted to temporarily reduce the city's inclusionary housing requirement for new market-rate projects from 15% to 5%.
Lurie is also moving ahead with plans to merge the Planning Department, Department of Building Inspection, and Permit Center functions into a new Department of Planning and Building following the passage of Proposition F. The merger is intended to streamline reviews and permitting, though the mayor's PermitSF initiative has faced scrutiny over its high cost and slow rollout. Lurie recently pushed through a contract extension with the contractor OpenGov without full support from the Board of Supervisors.
Mahmood said he expects the BUILD Act to come before the Board of Supervisors for a final vote before the end of the year.