Local
San Jose Public Defender Says ICE Agents Pepper-Sprayed Him While He Filmed Arrest
Deputy Public Defender David Oyer says he was pepper-sprayed by federal immigration agents near the Santa Clara County jail while documenting an arrest, then hospitalized and later filed a complaint with San Jose police. The incident raises questions about federal-local cooperation and the use of force by ICE.
A deputy public defender in San Jose says he was pepper-sprayed by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents while he was filming an arrest near the Santa Clara County Main Jail and Hall of Justice, an incident that has prompted a police investigation and renewed scrutiny of federal immigration tactics in the region.
David Oyer said he was walking past the county crime lab and jail on a recent afternoon when he noticed federal agents detaining someone and pulled out his phone to document the arrest. Moments later, he said, the situation escalated.
"I turned back and I saw the agents had started pushing one of the community members," Oyer said. "Looked like they were maybe pushing to try to disengage. Thatâs when out of nowhere the ICE agent grabbed his pepper spray."
Oyer said he was standing on the sidewalk and was not speaking to the agents or interfering with the arrest when he was sprayed. He described the pain as "excruciating" and said it was "probably the worst thing Iâve ever felt."
"Iâve broken bones and had surgeries," he said. "Itâs like your eyes are on fire for hours."
He went to a hospital for treatment, where medical staff used a device connected to an IV bag to flush his eyes with fluid, he said.
Oyer called San Jose police, who responded to a report of a disturbance. On Monday, he went to the police station to file a formal complaint against the agents.
"I think I was assaulted," he said. "I'd like to see due process take its course and for the individuals involved to be held accountable."
San Jose police said in an email that they are collecting evidence and that the circumstances surrounding the incident are under investigation.
The episode highlights a familiar tension between local authorities and federal immigration enforcement. Mike Leininger, a law enforcement analyst and retired San Jose police investigator, said Oyer will likely encounter what he called a federal roadblock.
"Thereâs going to be a problem," Leininger said. "The federal government has consistently not cooperated with local law enforcement."
Leininger also pointed to what he described as a pattern in ICE encounters.
"Their escalation seems to go up rapidly," he said. "I donât see very many de-escalation tactics being employed, and it seems that pepper spray is often their go-to."
ICE and the Department of Homeland Security did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
The incident comes as Santa Clara County and other Bay Area jurisdictions continue to navigate the boundaries between local policing and federal immigration enforcement. Public defenders and immigrant rights advocates have increasingly encouraged bystanders to document arrests, though they caution that doing so can carry risks.
For Oyer, the encounter has left him seeking accountability through the complaint process. Whether that process can reach federal agents remains an open question, one that local officials and community members will be watching closely.