Tuesday, November 17, 2026·Focal News

The San Francisco Focal

San Francisco's independent voice

Local

San Francisco Sheriff's Office Admits Illegally Recording Attorney-Client Jail Calls

Sheriff Paul Miyamoto acknowledged that jail staff recorded confidential conversations between public defenders and incarcerated clients and shared them with prosecutors, calling it an administrative error. Legal experts say the breach undermines the criminal justice system and warrants judicial oversight.

San Francisco Sheriff's Office Admits Illegally Recording Attorney-Client Jail Calls

San Francisco Sheriff Paul Miyamoto has acknowledged that his department illegally recorded confidential phone calls between public defenders and their incarcerated clients and shared those recordings with the District Attorney's Office, according to a letter sent to the Public Defender's Office last week.

The admission, first reported by NBC Bay Area, has prompted calls for judicial oversight and raised concerns about the integrity of criminal cases involving the affected attorneys.

Miyamoto described the incident as an administrative error that occurred inadvertently. In the letter, he said the problem was discovered in September and that jail staff have since updated public defender phone numbers to ensure they are placed on a "no record" list. He also said he has suspended the further release of recorded phone calls.

State law strictly prohibits the recording of privileged conversations between attorneys and their clients. While calls between inmates and their family and friends are routinely recorded and often shared with prosecutors, attorney-client communications are protected.

"It's absolutely illegal. It's actually a felony to record a privileged conversation between a client and an attorney," said Kwixuan Maloof, a deputy public defender.

Maloof is one of five deputy public defenders whose calls were recorded, according to the sheriff's letter. He said he discovered the breach in several ways: in one case by listening to a recording and hearing his own voice; in another, when an intern heard his voice on a recording; and in a third, when opposing counsel at the District Attorney's Office heard his voice and alerted him.

Legal analyst Steven Clark argued that the situation requires deeper intervention than the sheriff's remedial steps.

"This case suggests that judicial oversight is needed until this problem is completely fixed because it does undermine the entire criminal justice system," Clark said.

Clark added that any deputy district attorney who may have reviewed the recorded calls should recuse themselves from the corresponding cases.

The District Attorney's Office said in a prepared statement that it is taking the situation seriously and remains committed to transparency, but declined further comment.

The disclosure raises questions about how many other privileged calls may have been recorded and shared, and whether any criminal cases have been compromised as a result. Public defenders have argued that the breach violates defendants' constitutional right to counsel and could taint prosecutions.

The sheriff's office has not said whether it has notified all affected attorneys or whether any recordings were used in court proceedings. It also remains unclear whether an outside investigation will be conducted.

For now, the Public Defender's Office is calling for accountability, and legal observers say the incident underscores the need for stronger safeguards to protect confidential communications in the county jail system.

More from The San Francisco Focal