Local
PG&E's 2025 Reliability Report Excludes Massive San Francisco Blackout, Officials Say
PG&E claims major reliability gains in 2025, but its preferred metric omits the December substation fire that left a third of San Francisco without powerâsome for three days. City Attorney David Chiu and former regulators say the utility's numbers don't match residents' lived experience.
Pacific Gas and Electric is touting significant improvements in grid reliability for 2025, but the utility's headline metric excludes the kind of mass equipment failure that plunged a third of San Francisco into darkness last December, according to an investigation by NBC Bay Area.
The blackout, triggered by a fire at PG&E's Mission Substation south of Market Street, left some customers without power for as long as three days. PG&E has since acknowledged that maintenance lapses at the facility contributed to the fire and the subsequent outages.
In a September statement, PG&E CEO Patti Poppe said the company had boosted reliability by 30% over the previous two years. "Those are real results," she said. "They prove that PG&E can change. They prove that we are changing."
The report filed with state regulators found PG&E customers experienced 12% fewer outages on average compared with 2024, a record-bad year for blackout duration for the utility. Outages averaged nearly an hour less than in 2024, according to the filing. PG&E credited milder weather and more than 1,000 grid upgrades for the improvement.
"This progress reflects an intentional, company-wide commitment to reliability, with teams across PG&E working together to better serve our customers and communities," the utility said in a statement.
But the reliability metric PG&E citesâbased on standards set by the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineersâallows utilities to exclude certain extreme events, including major weather-related disasters and mass outages caused by equipment failure, from their overall performance calculations. The standards are intended to keep unusual events from distorting routine service measurements.
San Francisco City Attorney David Chiu, a frequent critic of the utility, said excluding weather is one thing but omitting failures tied to equipment problems or inadequate maintenance is another.
"The everyday experience of typical San Franciscans is that this is a system that's failing," Chiu said. "This does not jive with PG&E's own picture of reliability."
He compared PG&E's approach to a student boasting about a good grade while leaving out a failed final exam. "What we're talking about here are things that were completely within their control," he said.
Loretta Lynch, a former president of the California Public Utilities Commission, said excluding major equipment failures creates an incomplete picture.
"So PG&E's reliability report does not report on actual reliability," Lynch said. "What is the purpose of a reliability report if it doesn't actually report on all the blackouts that happened, especially the blackouts that were caused by PG&E's own equipment and maintenance failures?"
PG&E says it follows established industry standards accepted by state regulators. "The CPUC has specifically required us to use this standard," the company said in a statement, noting that it separately tracks outages involving major events under a different metric.
The gap between the two metrics is stark in San Francisco. The overall metric showed customers averaged 77 minutes without power. When the December substation failure and several smaller storm-related outages are included, the average time in the dark jumps to more than five hours.
"That's clearly unacceptable," Chiu said.
PG&E says it has continued to reduce outage times in San Francisco this year. But Chiu said the city has endured roughly one significant outage a week in 2025, a record that recently prompted city officials to urge state regulators to investigate the utility's performance.
The dispute comes as PG&E faces ongoing scrutiny over its maintenance practices and rate increases, with San Francisco officials arguing that the utility's reliability claims obscure the real burden borne by residents.