Local
Judge Signals Trial for Two San Francisco Shelter Workers Accused of Aiding Shooting Suspect
A San Francisco judge said prosecutors presented enough evidence to try two Bayshore Navigation Center employees for allegedly helping a suspect who shot and wounded a police officer evade capture. The judge will issue a formal ruling on Dec. 16 after additional arguments.
SAN FRANCISCO â Two homeless shelter workers are likely to stand trial on charges that they helped a suspect evade police after he allegedly shot and wounded a San Francisco police officer, a Superior Court judge said Friday.
Judge Dawn Payne said prosecutors had met their burden of proof at the conclusion of a contentious and long-delayed preliminary hearing for Oliver Barcenas and Erika Porter, both employees of the Bayshore Navigation Center. Payne said she would issue a formal ruling on Dec. 16 after lawyers submit additional arguments.
âI do think the people have met their burden,â Payne said. âBut maybe [the defense] will change my mind.â
Prosecutors and police allege that Barcenas, a supervisor, and Porter, a security aide, helped hide Norris Reed III at the shelter on May 31 after he fled following a shootout that critically wounded Officer Brittney Taylor. Reed, who was armed with two guns, took refuge at the shelter and sat in a courtyard for nearly 90 minutes while officers searched for him, according to testimony and video played in court.
Barcenas is accused of failing to call police to report Reedâs location and of giving Reed a jacket and hat when he asked for them. Porter is accused of misleading officers by telling them she had seen Reed running away from the shelter.
Both face two felony charges: acting as an accessory after the fact and obstructing or delaying a police officer. If convicted, they could face prison time. Barcenas, who was on probation at the time for a prior gun charge, could face additional time for violating probation.
The case has drawn scrutiny over what shelter officials describe as an overly aggressive response by the district attorneyâs office in a case involving a critically wounded officer. Defense attorneys and the former head of the shelter say the workers were caught between a rock and a hard place: Reed threatened them not to call police, and Barcenas was acting at the direction of his superior, an assistant director at the shelter, according to his lawyer.
The prosecutionâs case relies heavily on surveillance and body camera footage. Video played Friday appeared to show Barcenas handing Reed a jacket and hat through an open window. Body camera footage of officers questioning Porter showed her giving an incomplete account of where Reed was.
Surveillance footage showed workers startled by gunfire at about 10:45 p.m. on May 31, when the shootout between Reed and officers erupted. Minutes later, Reed was seen sprinting away from officers down Bayshore Boulevard, then doubling back at a walking pace and turning into the shelter. He idled in the courtyard for about a minute before following an unidentified worker inside through the front entrance.
Porter, who was at the front desk, screamed at Reed to leave, according to the video. Barcenas and others escorted Reed back into the courtyard and shut the front door. Porter, who was wrapping up her shift, packed her things and left through the back entrance toward her car. When an officer asked if she had seen Reed, she said she had been parked there the whole time and pointed down the street, saying she saw him running that way. She did not say Reed had been inside the shelter.
Body camera footage showed Porter shaking uncontrollably as she told officers she âdidnât want to get anybody in troubleâ and feared for her life. Her attorney, Rose Mishaan, acknowledged Porter did not give officers the full story but said Porter did not know Reed was hiding in the courtyard. Mishaan argued that Porterâs actions could amount to, at most, a misdemeanor.
âShe was just terrified,â Mishaan said outside the courtroom. âShe really didnât understand what was going on.â
Mishaan said the district attorneyâs office is treating the case more aggressively because it involved an officerâs potential loss of life. âTheyâre just kind of looking for people to blame,â she said.
Barcenasâ attorney, Gabriel Navarrette, called the evidence against his client âflimsy.â
âThere are just some facts that they are not going to be able to get because they just donât exist,â Navarrette said. Still, he acknowledged the judge may decide that the ultimate decision-maker will be a jury.
If the case goes to trial, the district attorneyâs office will have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Porter and Barcenas knowingly concealed Reed from police and helped him evade capture â a higher burden than at a preliminary hearing.
Barcenas and Porter were arrested and charged in August, two months after Reed was located and arrested after midnight on June 1. The judge will review final briefings on Dec. 10 and issue a ruling on Dec. 16.