Thursday, November 19, 2026·Focal News

The Portland Focal

Portland's independent voice

Politics

Eastern Oregon Governments Sue to Lift Kotek's Data Center Pause as NDAs Draw Scrutiny

The City of Umatilla and Umatilla County are taking Governor Tina Kotek to court over her pause on data center permits, arguing she overstepped her authority and jeopardizing billions in investment. Meanwhile, a nonprofit's records requests reveal that local governments signed nondisclosure agreements with Amazon, raising questions about transparency and environmental impacts.

Eastern Oregon Governments Sue to Lift Kotek's Data Center Pause as NDAs Draw Scrutiny

PENDLETON, Ore. — Local governments in Eastern Oregon are escalating their fight against Governor Tina Kotek's pause on new data center development, filing a court petition this month to force state regulators to resume processing environmental permits. The City of Umatilla and Umatilla County argue that Kotek exceeded her authority when she ordered the Oregon Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) to halt air and water pollution permits for new or expanding data centers until July.

The petition, filed Nov. 11 in circuit court, contends that the governor's order amounted to a "categorical suspension" of DEQ rules without properly amending or repealing them. Attorneys for the city and county are asking a judge to order the department to begin reviewing permit applications on their merits again. They warn that the pause threatens more than $1.2 billion in additional private investment that is being negotiated for the area but cannot proceed while permitting is frozen.

Kotek issued the pause in October, following her September call for a moratorium on data centers. The move came amid growing public concern over the industry's energy and water consumption, and its environmental footprint. A DEQ spokesperson, Antony Sparrow, declined to comment on the petition but said the agency continues work on draft permits until they reach the public comment stage, after which it complies with the governor's order.

The City of Umatilla declared an emergency over "financial loss" on Oct. 20, estimating the permit pause would cost $2.5 million in annual tax payments and $12 million in water infrastructure improvements, among other economic contributions from data centers.

As the legal battle unfolds, a La Grande-based nonprofit is shining a light on the secretive dealings between local governments and Amazon, the region's largest backer of data centers. Oregon Rural Action announced Tuesday that public records requests revealed nondisclosure agreements (NDAs) between Amazon and at least nine local governments in Umatilla and Morrow counties, including the City of Umatilla and Umatilla County.

The NDAs self-renew every three years and remain in effect for five years after termination, according to the nonprofit. Oregon Rural Action highlighted a 2017 email in which an Amazon representative declined to provide wastewater data to Hermiston City Manager Byron Smith unless the city signed an NDA.

"This is proof of what we already knew: that the data center boom here is built on a foundation of secrecy," said Hermiston resident Becky Davison in a statement released by the group. "We have serious questions about how much water data centers are using, how contaminated their wastewater is and where it goes, and Amazon is using NDAs to hide the answers from the public."

Amazon did not respond to a request for comment. Last month, the company pledged to stop using NDAs with local governments, but the agreements with Eastern Oregon governments were signed before that announcement.

The controversy has not deterred other communities from pursuing data center development. The city of Irrigon, a town of about 2,000 people situated between the data center hubs of Boardman and Umatilla, recently commissioned an economic analysis that recommends opening hundreds of acres to data center construction.

Data centers have become a flashpoint in Oregon politics, with recent survey data showing broad unpopularity among voters. Kotek's moratorium and permit pause reflect that sentiment, but local officials in Umatilla argue the industry is vital to their economies. The court petition is expected to be heard in the coming weeks.

More from The Portland Focal