Politics
Sole Bidder for I-5 Bridge Replacement Raises Cost and Accountability Concerns
A joint venture including Kiewit, a contractor with a history of cost overruns, is the only bidder to design the multibillion-dollar Interstate 5 bridge replacement. Lawmakers and watchdogs worry the lack of competition gives the states little leverage to control costs.
The Interstate Bridge Replacement Program, the long-planned effort to rebuild the aging span connecting Portland and Vancouver, Washington, has received just one design bidâfrom a joint venture that includes a contractor with a recent record of major cost overruns in Oregon and elsewhere.
The sole bidder, Columbia River Constructors, is a partnership of Guy F. Atkinson Construction, Traylor Bros. Inc., and Kiewit Engineering Group, which would lead the work. Kiewit, a subsidiary of Nebraska-based Kiewit Corp., is one of the nation's largest contractors. Its Oregon projects include the Interstate 205 Abernethy Bridge in Oregon City, which is now more than two years behind schedule and has an estimated cost of $800 millionâmore than triple the original $250 million price tag in 2018. The company also received negative marks on four consecutive annual performance reviews by the Oregon Department of Transportation dating back to 2022, according to the Portland Daily Journal of Commerce.
In Maryland, officials dropped Kiewit from the second phase of rebuilding the Francis Scott Key Bridge after it collapsed in 2024. Gov. Wes Moore said in April that working with the company was not in the state's best interest, calling the price tag and timeline "unreasonably high and therefore unacceptable."
Kiewit spokesperson Bob Kula said the company does not comment on potential project pursuits but added that "we stand behind our long track record delivering complex transportation projects across the U.S."
The single-bid situation drew concern at a Monday meeting of the Joint Oregon-Washington Legislative Action Committee overseeing the project. Oregon state Rep. Thủy Trần, D-Portland, and state Sen. Bruce Starr, R-Dundee, asked program administrators how they plan to hold Kiewit and the other contractors accountable and manage costs.
"Having multiple bidders is important to protect the taxpayers. If you only have one bidder, they can bid whatever they want," said Washington state Rep. Ed Orcutt, a Kalama Republican and co-chair of the joint committee. "Either we pay them or we don't get the project."
Economist Joe Cortright, who leads the Portland-based think tank City Observatory and attended the meeting, told lawmakers that the lack of competition puts the two states in a weak bargaining position. "You are in an active dispute with Kiewit," Cortright said, referring to the Abernethy Bridge overruns. "You know that they go over budget, and you've been unable to negotiate with them."
The bridge program itself has already seen its cost estimate balloon. In 2022 it was slated to cost up to $7.5 billion; by March of this year, transportation officials announced a new price tag closer to $14.4 billion.
Washington state transportation official John White said the project will use a progressive design-build approach, which brings the owner, designer and contractor together early in the design process and is known for greater cost certainty and transparent pricing.
Some lawmakers expressed comfort with the single bid. Oregon state Rep. Susan McLain, D-Forest Grove, said in an email that the three firms will bring together a wider range of resources, expertise and accountability. "There are very few firms in the country that have the capacity or experience needed to take on a project of this size," McLain said. "It is not uncommon for this kind of infrastructure work to have a small number of submitters ⦠Moving ahead with a new, seismically resilient bridge is critical to the safety and economic wellbeing of our region."
Washington state Rep. Jake Fey, D-Tacoma, who chairs the House Transportation Committee, agreed that multiple bidders are preferable but said it can be difficult with large projects. "I am not concerned," he said. "There were two firms that were interested and they decided to collaborate. What are you going to do? If you can't make a deal with them, then we go back to the process of seeking qualified bidders."
Washington Gov. Bob Ferguson has said a construction contract will be awarded next year, with cars potentially driving across the new span by 2035âroughly two years later than previously announced.
The single-bid development comes as the project faces scrutiny over its mounting costs and the accountability of the firms involved. For a region that depends on the I-5 crossing for daily commuting and freight movement, the stakes are high: the current bridge is more than a century old and vulnerable to earthquakes, and officials say a replacement is critical to safety and the economy.