Local
State Labor Bureau Reverses Ruling, Reviving 64-Unit Affordable Housing Project in Astoria
After a court ruling forced a reversal, Oregon's labor bureau will no longer require union-scale wages on a stalled Astoria hotel conversion, saving the project $2.5 million and clearing the way for dozens of affordable apartments.
The Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries has reversed its earlier decision requiring prevailing wages on a proposed affordable housing development in Astoria, a move that will save the project approximately $2.5 million and allow construction to proceed after a nearly two-year delay.
The project, known as Copeland Commons, would convert the long-vacant State Hotel in downtown Astoria into 64 affordable apartments. The development was spearheaded by Bill Van Nostran, a now-retired minister at First Presbyterian Church, who formed a nonprofit to address Clatsop County's homelessness rateâthe highest in Oregon.
In January 2025, BOLI informed Van Nostran's team that the conversion did not qualify as "residential construction" under state law and therefore would be subject to prevailing wage requirements. That ruling added $2.5 million to the project's cost and brought construction to a halt.
The reversal came on Nov. 3, after the Oregon Court of Appeals ruled in September on a similar dispute involving a Salem affordable housing project. The court found that BOLI had misinterpreted the law, writing that "the Legislature intended for the [prevailing wage] exemption to cover affordable housing, regardless of whether it uses some materials from a previous building."
In a letter to Van Nostran's group, BOLI Commissioner Christina Stephenson wrote that "prevailing wage rate laws do not apply to projects for residential construction that are privately owned and that predominantly provide affordable housing."
Van Nostran said the decision vindicates his years-long effort. "The permission NOT to pay prevailing wages should save us approximately $2.5 million in construction costs," he said. He also credited media coverage of BOLI's earlier ruling with drawing attention to the issue, saying it "created quite a stirâboth locally, as well as in Portland and, perhaps, around the state."
BOLI spokeswoman Rachel Mann said the agency was simply responding to the appellate court's decision. "BOLI's actions in this case reflect the agency's proactive commitment to ensuring that its pending determinations are informed by the most recent and applicable legal authority when they are issued," Mann said.
The case highlights a broader debate over how Oregon applies prevailing wage laws to affordable housing at a time when the state faces the nation's second-highest homelessness rate, trailing only New York. Developers have long argued that BOLI, under Stephenson's leadership, has routinely required union-scale wages on projects that should be exempt, adding 10% to 20% to construction costs.
State Sen. Dick Anderson, a Lincoln City Republican who serves as vice chair of the Senate Housing Committee, welcomed the news but criticized the agency's initial stance. "Copeland Commons never should have been a fight," Anderson said. "The Legislature wrote this exemption for exactly this kind of project, and it took a Court of Appeals ruling to get a Democratic state agency to follow it."
Anderson has introduced Senate Bill 1566 to clarify prevailing wage laws and accelerate affordable housing construction. He said the 2027 legislative session will test whether Democratic leaders are serious about addressing the housing crisis. "Housing providers shouldn't have to sue to get the law applied as written," he said.
Despite the court's ruling, significant disagreements remain over how prevailing wage law applies to other affordable housing projects, including those financed through the state's Local Innovation and Fast Track program and situations where public infrastructure work occurs near private developments. BOLI's position on the latter issue has stalled a major project in Eugene.
For now, Astoria is poised to gain dozens of new affordable homes in a building that had sat largely empty for more than 50 yearsâa small but symbolic victory in a state grappling with a deepening housing emergency.