Local
Federal Appeals Court to Rule Friday on Last-Ditch Bid to Halt Detroit Lake Drawdown
The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers could begin lowering Detroit Lake as early as Saturday morning, while Marion County and downstream cities ask the Ninth Circuit to block a plan they say threatens drinking water for hundreds of thousands of residents.
The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers could begin a deep drawdown of Detroit Lake as soon as Saturday morning, according to court documents filed Tuesday, setting up a high-stakes collision with Marion County and the cities of Salem and Stayton, which are asking a federal appeals court to block the operation.
The Army Corps said it may start lowering the reservoir at 9 a.m. Saturday. The agency has spent months planning to bring the lake down to help threatened Chinook salmon pass more easily through Detroit Dam and continue downstream, a step required under a separate court order.
Marion County, Salem and Stayton sued in federal court in July to stop the drawdown, arguing it would severely damage local water systems and endanger supplies for residents downstream. In an emergency appeal filed Tuesday with the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, the local governments said the operation would "endanger clean drinking water for hundreds of thousands of Marion County residents, threatening irreparable harm to schools, hospitals, businesses, farmers, recreation, fish, public services, and the environment."
The appeal came after U.S. District Judge Mustafa Kasubhai on Nov. 4 rejected Marion County's request for a preliminary injunction to halt the winter drawdown. The county filed its appeal with the Ninth Circuit within 24 hours.
Both sides have until Friday morning to submit supporting documentation, and the appellate court is expected to rule sometime Friday afternoon â a timeline that leaves little room before the Corps' possible Saturday start.
Local officials point to a 2023 drawdown at Green Peter Lake as a cautionary example. In that case, the Army Corps lowered the reservoir rapidly, churning up large amounts of sediment. The muddy water overwhelmed treatment plants in Lebanon and Sweet Home, and the abrupt change in water depth killed thousands of kokanee salmon.
Army Corps officials have said they expect any increase in turbidity at Detroit to be minimal and do not anticipate problems for local drinking water facilities. They say the Detroit drawdown will be far more gradual than the Green Peter operation and will unfold over multiple years.
At a virtual public meeting Wednesday, Corps fish biologist Greg Taylor said the reservoir was lowered to similar levels in 2015 and 2019, and that refilling those years did not cause problems.
The dispute sits at the intersection of two federal obligations: protecting threatened salmon runs and safeguarding the drinking water relied on by communities across the Willamette Valley. For residents downstream, the question is whether the Corps' gradual approach will be gentle enough to keep sediment out of the taps â and whether the courts will let the work begin before they get an answer.