Thursday, November 19, 2026·Focal News

The Portland Focal

Portland's independent voice

Local

Portland Parents Challenge School Closure Plan Ahead of Dec. 15 Board Vote

Parents and the teachers union are pressing Portland Public Schools to justify its plan to close 10 schools, pointing to confusing staffing projections, overcrowded receiving schools, and unanswered questions about transportation and support services before the board votes Dec. 15.

Portland Parents Challenge School Closure Plan Ahead of Dec. 15 Board Vote

Portland Public Schools' push to close 10 schools and consolidate programs is facing mounting scrutiny from parents and educators who say the district has failed to explain how the plan will affect staffing, transportation, and classroom capacity — concerns that could shape a school board vote scheduled for Dec. 15.

At the center of the dispute is a discrepancy in Superintendent Kimberlee Armstrong's recommendation memo. According to Alexis Córdova, a software engineer and Irvington Elementary parent, the district would cut more than 260 positions if it kept all schools open. Under the closure plan, it would cut more than 300.

"There will literally be less FTE to go around for everybody even though they're saying that it is going to be better," Córdova said Tuesday at a meeting organized by the Portland Association of Teachers.

Córdova, whose second grader attends Irvington — one of the schools slated to close — said the numbers led him down a "rabbit hole" and ultimately to publish his own analysis of the district's materials. "PPS essentially has created a universe where 2+2 equals a range of numbers," he said.

District officials dispute that characterization. Richard Smith, PPS senior director of data and accountability, said the district will "re-invest" the roughly 40-position difference between the two scenarios, meaning staffing levels would be the same whether or not schools close. But the memo offers few specifics: one page outlines how a smaller re-investment of 15 to 20 staff would be distributed across the 19 schools set to absorb students from closing campuses.

PAT President Alisha Chavez said the district still has not produced an adequate plan. "We still don't know what staffing's gonna look like, transportation, the supports for our students who have individual education programs," Chavez said Wednesday on OPB's "Think Out Loud." She added: "I have not seen a staffing model about what our schools will look like and what well-resourced schools actually are for our students."

Capacity at receiving schools is another flashpoint. Representatives from Beach, Sitton, and James John elementary schools wrote to district officials Monday warning that Chief Joseph Elementary will be "too full on day one" when Beach students arrive. The letter said a crowded Chief Joseph would lack space for specialized supports Beach students need, including rooms for speech and language services, therapy, and de-escalation.

At Martin Luther King Jr. Elementary in Northeast Portland, functional capacity is 584 students; projected enrollment next fall, after Sabin Elementary students move over, is 572. The district says it will conduct a site review if utilization exceeds 100%. Meanwhile, James John and Sitton are each projected to enroll fewer than 260 students, and three middle schools are projected below 400.

PPS defines a sustainable school as one with at least 360 K-5 students or 500 middle school students, offering a range of academics, electives, counseling, and nursing support. Under Armstrong's recommendation, 50% of K-5 schools would meet that threshold, up from 18% now, and 47% of middle schools, up from 13%. Smith said the plan puts the district on a "path to sustainability," though it will not reach that goal with this plan alone.

Córdova also questions the enrollment forecasts underpinning the district's modeling. Portland State University's projections for Irvington have been off in recent years, he said. Ethan Sharygin, director of PSU's Population Research Center, said districtwide errors are under 2% within five years, but individual school projections can vary widely — in one group of seven Southwest Portland elementary schools, net error for the group was 1.1%, while individual schools ranged from 0.4% to 10%.

Armstrong defended the timeline in her memo. "Change is hard for school communities, and PPS does not take these decisions lightly," she wrote. "But these decisions have been delayed long enough, and acting now puts the district on a more stable footing for every student."

Portland is not alone. Salem-Keizer and Tigard-Tualatin are also planning closures, and other Oregon districts are weighing similar moves amid declining enrollment. A state revenue forecast released Wednesday projects school enrollment will fall by 69,500 students, or 12.9%, over the next decade.

Board members raised their own questions at Tuesday's meeting and said they plan to file amendments to the superintendent's recommendation. Board chair Eddie Wang asked members to submit amendments by Nov. 30, with discussion set for a Dec. 1 board meeting and a possible Dec. 2 committee session. If the board approves a closure plan, the district said it will spend January through March developing school-specific transition plans.

More from The Portland Focal