Friday, November 20, 2026·Focal News

The Phoenix Focal

Phoenix's independent voice

Politics

Arizona Schools Chief-Elect Terry Leyba Ruiz Targets Voucher Auto-Approvals in ESA Overhaul

Superintendent-elect Terry Leyba Ruiz, a Democrat taking office in January, pledged to end the $2,000 automatic approval process for Arizona's Empowerment Scholarship Account vouchers and invest in crumbling public schools, with Democratic control of the Legislature making changes more likely.

Arizona Schools Chief-Elect Terry Leyba Ruiz Targets Voucher Auto-Approvals in ESA Overhaul

PHOENIX — Arizona Superintendent of Public Instruction-elect Terry Leyba Ruiz said Thursday she will move to overhaul the state's school voucher program and redirect investment toward public schools, setting up a confrontation over the Empowerment Scholarship Account program as Democrats prepare to take unified control of state government for the first time in more than six decades.

Ruiz, a Democrat who takes office in January, said the state's public schools are in crisis. "Our schools are closing. Teachers are leaving and students are facing the consequences. Our taxpayer dollars are subsidizing diamond rings and lingerie. Our proficiency rates are declining," she said.

Declining enrollment and budget shortfalls have forced dozens of campuses to close in recent years, and Ruiz said those still operating are deteriorating. "When we say we're 49th in the nation, what that means is our schools are crumbling around our students. Literally, gyms are held up with hydraulic jack lifts and scaffolding. So the need is real," she said.

At the center of her agenda is the ESA voucher program, which has drawn scrutiny over fraud and oversight gaps. Ruiz said she is committed to "ending the $2,000 auto approval process" and wants to bring in technology that would flag unallowable purchases while processing legitimate transactions faster. She also pointed to staffing vacancies at the department that oversees the program, saying they offer an opportunity to strengthen an agency in need of support.

Her proposals may find a more receptive audience at the Capitol. Democrats won control of both legislative chambers in this month's elections, and will hold the governor's office, House and Senate simultaneously for the first time since the 1960s. "With a teacher serving as superintendent of public instruction, alongside our new educators serving in leadership in a pro-public-education legislative majority, the possibilities for our schools are endless," Ruiz said.

State Sen.-elect Aaron Lieberman, a Paradise Valley Democrat who will chair the Senate Appropriations Committee, said the voucher program needs new oversight and predicted real changes in the coming session. "We've got to look at every single dollar and make sure we're smartly investing it to make the greatest impact on the most number of our Arizona kids. And there will be real changes to the ESA program in this first legislative session for sure," Lieberman said.

Lieberman argued the state's spending on the program is disproportionate to its overall budget. "Look, Texas spends like 130 billion a year and spends a billion dollars on ESAs. We spend $18 billion a year and we spend a billion on ESAs. Those numbers are totally out of whack, right? It just does not make sense," he said.

A new report from the Common Sense Institute, a free-market policy group, found that ESA students receive less funding per pupil than public school students and that less than 2% of program spending went toward purchases that should not have been approved — a finding that voucher supporters are likely to cite as lawmakers debate new restrictions.

The debate carries high stakes for Arizona families and school districts. Public school advocates have argued that universal vouchers divert money from classrooms as districts grapple with closures, while voucher supporters say the program gives parents options and saves the state money. With Democrats now holding the levers of state government, the 2027 legislative session is expected to be the first real test of whether Ruiz's promised accountability measures become law.

More from The Phoenix Focal